AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!
U21 Loan Watch
U21 Loan Watch
I don’t know about you, but I love it when a player makes it through the ranks to become a first team regular. Unfortunately, it doesn’t happen often these days. This is a shame because giving young players a chance is an area where we could have an edge over the traditional top 6.
The current crop give me some cause for optimism, having won the FA Youth Cup and U18 League South a couple of seasons back. Maybe two or three can make it. No fewer than eight U21 players have gone out on a season loan to lower league clubs. Meanwhile, Casey, Scarles and Orford remain at the club. Hopefully, they will get a few minutes on the pitch, but I’m not holding my breath. Mubama had a few chances last season but mostly disappointed with his lack of technique. Inexplicably, he has now joined Man City to give Haaland competition.
So, to the eight who are currently out on loan. How are they getting on?
1. Callum Marshall - Huddersfield (League One). After a disappointing loan spell at West Brom last season, Marshall has dropped down to League One. So far, he has done quite well and already found the net. Yesterday, he played for 67 minutes before being replaced.
2. George Earthy - Bristol City (Championship). A lot of great things expected of Earthy. He didn’t make the squad yesterday. Is he injured?
3. Michael Forbes - Bristol Rovers (League One). Did not make the squad.
4. Freddie Potts - Portsmouth (Championship). Player of the season at Wycombe last year, but unused sub yesterday.
5. Krisztian Hegyi - Motherwell (Scottish Premier). Unused sub.
6. Patrick Kelly - Doncaster (League Two). Came on in the 78th minute.
7. Levi Laing - Cheltenham (League Two). Unused sub.
8. Gideon Kodua - Wycombe (League One). Came on in the 88th minute.
I make that 81 minutes of football between 8 players yesterday. Early days but a bit worrying. I’ll keep this updated throughout the season (if I can be bothered).
The current crop give me some cause for optimism, having won the FA Youth Cup and U18 League South a couple of seasons back. Maybe two or three can make it. No fewer than eight U21 players have gone out on a season loan to lower league clubs. Meanwhile, Casey, Scarles and Orford remain at the club. Hopefully, they will get a few minutes on the pitch, but I’m not holding my breath. Mubama had a few chances last season but mostly disappointed with his lack of technique. Inexplicably, he has now joined Man City to give Haaland competition.
So, to the eight who are currently out on loan. How are they getting on?
1. Callum Marshall - Huddersfield (League One). After a disappointing loan spell at West Brom last season, Marshall has dropped down to League One. So far, he has done quite well and already found the net. Yesterday, he played for 67 minutes before being replaced.
2. George Earthy - Bristol City (Championship). A lot of great things expected of Earthy. He didn’t make the squad yesterday. Is he injured?
3. Michael Forbes - Bristol Rovers (League One). Did not make the squad.
4. Freddie Potts - Portsmouth (Championship). Player of the season at Wycombe last year, but unused sub yesterday.
5. Krisztian Hegyi - Motherwell (Scottish Premier). Unused sub.
6. Patrick Kelly - Doncaster (League Two). Came on in the 78th minute.
7. Levi Laing - Cheltenham (League Two). Unused sub.
8. Gideon Kodua - Wycombe (League One). Came on in the 88th minute.
I make that 81 minutes of football between 8 players yesterday. Early days but a bit worrying. I’ll keep this updated throughout the season (if I can be bothered).
-
- Posts: 2132
- Old WHO Number: 214368
- Has liked: 78 times
- Been liked: 418 times
-
- Posts: 3301
- Old WHO Number: 321173
- Has liked: 56 times
- Been liked: 402 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Earthy on after 70
Potts on at 0-3 after 64
Portsmouth managing their players over Xmas with Potts on the bench with Lang who scored 4 the other day
Potts on at 0-3 after 64
Portsmouth managing their players over Xmas with Potts on the bench with Lang who scored 4 the other day
-
- Posts: 2132
- Old WHO Number: 214368
- Has liked: 78 times
- Been liked: 418 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Iron Duke" wrote: ↑29 Dec 2024, 14:24 Earthy v Potts again today, but both of them find themselves on the bench. Potts is probably being rested, while Earthy continues to be a mere squad player for Manning.
Stuck on the bench and 3-0 down, expect an appearance early in the second half.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
No. 7 Callum Marshall impressing yet again for his Loan Club in a big game win for them against Stockport...
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Just checked and yesterday Bristol Rovers got a very credible 1-1 draw at home to Disney Plus. Elliott Lee scored for them.
Unfortunately for Forbes, he got taken off injured after 22 minutes. Hopefully nothing serious.
Unfortunately for Forbes, he got taken off injured after 22 minutes. Hopefully nothing serious.
Re: U21 Loan Watch
I went to Birmingham v Bristol Rovers last week. It was a very good atmosphere there with 26,000 fans making plenty of noise. Proper old fashioned football ground.
Forbes was playing for Rovers. He didn’t do too badly in the first half but they are an awful side. He got outmuscled early in the second half and was soon replaced.
Forbes was playing for Rovers. He didn’t do too badly in the first half but they are an awful side. He got outmuscled early in the second half and was soon replaced.
- Snodders' Beard
- Posts: 52
- Has liked: 154 times
- Been liked: 14 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Fauxstralian wrote: ↑21 Dec 2024, 14:34 Freddie Potts played 90mins in Portsmouth’s 4-1 smashing of Fat Franks Coventry
Patrick Kelly scores in Doncaster’s 3-1 win over Tranmere
Couple of assists as well, bit generous for the 1st as Lang had a fair bit to do afterwards and rifled in an absolute rocket of a shot but the 2nd was a pretty decent corner taken by Potts.
-
- Posts: 3301
- Old WHO Number: 321173
- Has liked: 56 times
- Been liked: 402 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Freddie Potts played 90mins in Portsmouth’s 4-1 smashing of Fat Franks Coventry
Patrick Kelly scores in Doncaster’s 3-1 win over Tranmere
Patrick Kelly scores in Doncaster’s 3-1 win over Tranmere
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Iron Duke" wrote: ↑21 Dec 2024, 08:46 Well done, Marshall.
2 goals, an assist, and 90 minutes played.
And Man of the the Match. A complete performance.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Yeah, it feels to me like he may begin to go on a bit of a run if he scores again at home to Stockport.
What I'd give to see him score again giving echoes of that fantastic 10 game consecutive goal scoring run by Defoe for Bournemouth in League One over 20 years ago now.
I didn't know he got an assist as well, fucking great stuff.
What I'd give to see him score again giving echoes of that fantastic 10 game consecutive goal scoring run by Defoe for Bournemouth in League One over 20 years ago now.
I didn't know he got an assist as well, fucking great stuff.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
My boy Callum Marshall has now got 2 in 2 games for Huddersfield tonight, 3 goals in his last 5 matches. 6th goal and 2 assists for the season. Keep it up...
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
twoleftfeet wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 14:01Massive Attack" wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:18twoleftfeet wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:15Very underwhelming so far, very little involvement.
Ashby looks good though.It would help if they tried to give him the ball when he keeps asking for it. When he does briefly get hold of it you can tell the difference in quality on the ball.
And yes Ashby has looked solid as a makeshift left back. 23 now and still not established himself in the Premier League which shows you how long it can take to make it at that level as a promising youth player..He just seems to play short passes, I want to see him take players on.
Not his game. He's all about keeping possession flowing and effecting the final 3rd. It was his pass to the player who got fouled edge of the box for Bristol Citys Free kick that was scored.
- Full Claret Jacket
- Posts: 281
- Location: Fortunes always hiding.....
- Old WHO Number: 209345
- Has liked: 26 times
- Been liked: 45 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Massive Attack" wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:18twoleftfeet wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:15Very underwhelming so far, very little involvement.
Ashby looks good though.It would help if they tried to give him the ball when he keeps asking for it. When he does briefly get hold of it you can tell the difference in quality on the ball.
And yes Ashby has looked solid as a makeshift left back. 23 now and still not established himself in the Premier League which shows you how long it can take to make it at that level as a promising youth player..
Ashby has played all over the pitch for them. Not been amazing really in any of them. Just become a utility player when someone else is injured. I'm glad he left and actually is getting some game time somewhere but he's a long way from a top player at a top Championship or Premier League club and you can't hold players back forever who will probably never make it. Newcastle was a totally duff move.
-
- Posts: 2132
- Old WHO Number: 214368
- Has liked: 78 times
- Been liked: 418 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Massive Attack" wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:18twoleftfeet wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:15Very underwhelming so far, very little involvement.
Ashby looks good though.It would help if they tried to give him the ball when he keeps asking for it. When he does briefly get hold of it you can tell the difference in quality on the ball.
And yes Ashby has looked solid as a makeshift left back. 23 now and still not established himself in the Premier League which shows you how long it can take to make it at that level as a promising youth player..
He just seems to play short passes, I want to see him take players on.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
- Manuel
- Posts: 4111
- Location: The Very Far East
- Old WHO Number: 300109
- Has liked: 137 times
- Been liked: 438 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
Cor, look at some of you uber fans watching and analyzing our loan players lol.
Having a look at Cov v Hull, Cov one down to bottom of the table Hull and booed off at ht, poor old fatty. Championship football is fucking shit though.
Having a look at Cov v Hull, Cov one down to bottom of the table Hull and booed off at ht, poor old fatty. Championship football is fucking shit though.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4858
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2769 times
- Been liked: 1362 times
Re: U21 Loan Watch
twoleftfeet wrote: ↑14 Dec 2024, 13:15Very underwhelming so far, very little involvement.
Ashby looks good though.
It would help if they tried to give him the ball when he keeps asking for it. When he does briefly get hold of it you can tell the difference in quality on the ball.
And yes Ashby has looked solid as a makeshift left back. 23 now and still not established himself in the Premier League which shows you how long it can take to make it at that level as a promising youth player..
And yes Ashby has looked solid as a makeshift left back. 23 now and still not established himself in the Premier League which shows you how long it can take to make it at that level as a promising youth player..
-
- Posts: 2132
- Old WHO Number: 214368
- Has liked: 78 times
- Been liked: 418 times