AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!
Tragic Diouf v Scarles
-
- Posts: 770
- Been liked: 186 times
Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Had a perfectly good academy kid ready to go and Cock Piss drops 20m on a left back we didn't need when cash is scarce.
Unless there's a massive improvement on that performance expect Scarles to start the season.
Unless there's a massive improvement on that performance expect Scarles to start the season.
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Oh for sure, largely so that we have someone to pass sit the other direction to Bowen or Wan Bissaka who can be relied upon to do something with it. Paqueta is a lefty but does his creative work through the middle.
-
- Posts: 350
- Old WHO Number: 15391
- Has liked: 661 times
- Been liked: 123 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Gank wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 23:18eusebiovic wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 22:40 From what I watched of the game which was about 60 minutes - I kept seeing Diouf make the runs in the first half but none of our pedestrian, one footed, predominantly right footed elephant snails in midfield seemed capable of threading a pass out to the left wing. So we certainly need a deep lying, left footed midfielder unless Scarles is capable of doing that role which he has often done in the development team.You don't want a left footer passing it left to the left wing.
A bit of balance in there might free up some space though eh?
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
eusebiovic wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 22:40 From what I watched of the game which was about 60 minutes - I kept seeing Diouf make the runs in the first half but none of our pedestrian, one footed, predominantly right footed elephant snails in midfield seemed capable of threading a pass out to the left wing. So we certainly need a deep lying, left footed midfielder unless Scarles is capable of doing that role which he has often done in the development team.
You don't want a left footer passing it left to the left wing.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
What we need is to stop over relying on Bowen, Wan-Bissaka and Soucek to set up or score our goals. Hopefully Diouf and/or Scarles can readdress that down the left flank.
-
- Posts: 350
- Old WHO Number: 15391
- Has liked: 661 times
- Been liked: 123 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
From what I watched of the game which was about 60 minutes - I kept seeing Diouf make the runs in the first half but none of our pedestrian, one footed, predominantly right footed elephant snails in midfield seemed capable of threading a pass out to the left wing. So we certainly need a deep lying, left footed midfielder unless Scarles is capable of doing that role which he has often done in the development team.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
-
- Posts: 90
- Old WHO Number: 21583
- Has liked: 23 times
- Been liked: 11 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Scarles is a left back, who's not very good going forward. ( yes he's a kid and one of our own etc ) Diouf is a wing back and is very good going forward. We played 532 therefore you need a wing back.
-
- Posts: 770
- Been liked: 186 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:57THUNDERCLINT wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:49Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:40I don’t think he's even that forward. He's more like a cuck in a closet peeping through the gap waiting patiently for his turn to clean-up right at the end if he's lucky.So Potter is Pickle?I have NEVER seen them both in the same room, but then again maybe 1 of them was in the cupboard..
We've hired Pickle in a Potter gimp mask?
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
He was waiting loads of time to get the ball only for us to cycle it back round. For then the midfield to lose the ball.
if you notice he was playing very high up on the left but if you don't give him the ball what is he supposed to do.
Agurd seem to not want to give it to him...
if you notice he was playing very high up on the left but if you don't give him the ball what is he supposed to do.
Agurd seem to not want to give it to him...
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
THUNDERCLINT wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:49Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:40I don’t think he's even that forward. He's more like a cuck in a closet peeping through the gap waiting patiently for his turn to clean-up right at the end if he's lucky.So Potter is Pickle?
I have NEVER seen them both in the same room, but then again maybe 1 of them was in the cupboard..


-
- Posts: 770
- Been liked: 186 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:40THUNDERCLINT wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:22Vexed wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:02Well he's fifth choice left back at the minute behind Diouf, AWB, Emerson and KWP. Obviously Emerson is off and AWB cant play both flanks simultaneously but he's still well down the list. Half decent defender, got nothing going forward. That wont be a Potter-friendly trait. I also dont care if you agree or not.He's all finger, no fuck.I don’t think he's even that forward. He's more like a cuck in a closet peeping through the gap waiting patiently for his turn to clean-up right at the end if he's lucky.
So Potter is Pickle?
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
THUNDERCLINT wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:22Vexed wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:02Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 12:53A player who got two man of the match performances away against quality sides last season, amongst some other good performances. For his age to do that bursting on the scene, that's an outstanding thing to do.
It really was that Anfield appearance that stuck out most but then that was against the Champions elect and 1 of the best Forwards to ever play in the Premier League at the height of his game. Average on a good day my arse.Well he's fifth choice left back at the minute behind Diouf, AWB, Emerson and KWP. Obviously Emerson is off and AWB cant play both flanks simultaneously but he's still well down the list. Half decent defender, got nothing going forward. That wont be a Potter-friendly trait. I also dont care if you agree or not.He's all finger, no fuck.
I don’t think he's even that forward. He's more like a cuck in a closet peeping through the gap waiting patiently for his turn to clean-up right at the end if he's lucky.
-
- Posts: 770
- Been liked: 186 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Vexed wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 13:02Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 12:53A player who got two man of the match performances away against quality sides last season, amongst some other good performances. For his age to do that bursting on the scene, that's an outstanding thing to do.
It really was that Anfield appearance that stuck out most but then that was against the Champions elect and 1 of the best Forwards to ever play in the Premier League at the height of his game. Average on a good day my arse.Well he's fifth choice left back at the minute behind Diouf, AWB, Emerson and KWP. Obviously Emerson is off and AWB cant play both flanks simultaneously but he's still well down the list. Half decent defender, got nothing going forward. That wont be a Potter-friendly trait. I also dont care if you agree or not.
Point of order, Cock Piss doesn't give a shit about going forward.
He's all finger, no fuck.
He's all finger, no fuck.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
It's all good for debate, it's not my fault you can't spot a talent when it's staring you in the face. I had similar discussions with others regarding Ferguson who apparently isn't all that either. 
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
Massive Attack" wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 12:53A player who got two man of the match performances away against quality sides last season, amongst some other good performances. For his age to do that bursting on the scene, that's an outstanding thing to do.
It really was that Anfield appearance that stuck out most but then that was against the Champions elect and 1 of the best Forwards to ever play in the Premier League at the height of his game. Average on a good day my arse.
Well he's fifth choice left back at the minute behind Diouf, AWB, Emerson and KWP. Obviously Emerson is off and AWB cant play both flanks simultaneously but he's still well down the list. Half decent defender, got nothing going forward. That wont be a Potter-friendly trait. I also dont care if you agree or not.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
A player who got two man of the match performances away against quality sides last season, amongst some other good performances. For his age to do that bursting on the scene against high quality Premier League opposition, that's an outstanding thing to achieve.
It really was that Anfield appearance that stuck out most but then that was against the Champions elect and 1 of the best Forwards to ever play in the Premier League at the height of his game. Average on a good day my arse.
It really was that Anfield appearance that stuck out most but then that was against the Champions elect and 1 of the best Forwards to ever play in the Premier League at the height of his game. Average on a good day my arse.
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
If it wasn't for the Ebola Cup I'd have Scarles out on loan, think he needs game time. Diouf didn't look up to much yesterday but the tactics were terrible/non existent and the entire team played like cunts. Bit unfair to single him out and then proclaim the 'average on a good day' Scarles is the better player. Fucking dense.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 4847
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 2761 times
- Been liked: 1355 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
My issue with the Diouf signing was prioritising £20M on a position that wasn't the most pressing concern, yet that was his first priority to address.
On top of that apparently we have to watch the pennies, so then this signing happens, none of it makes much sense or smart management to me.
And just as Scarles was growing in to the 1st Team position with mainly positive performances against Premier League opposition, he's now been demoted back down as 2nd, possibly 3rd choice or worse could be sent out on loan. If that happens I think that would be terrible after making his Premier League breakthrough as an impressive 19yo with raw but clear talent.
It would also send a bad signal to the other Academy players that even someone as good as Scarles at his age making decent performances at a high level, you're still likely to be sent out on loan starting the process all over again.
On top of that apparently we have to watch the pennies, so then this signing happens, none of it makes much sense or smart management to me.
And just as Scarles was growing in to the 1st Team position with mainly positive performances against Premier League opposition, he's now been demoted back down as 2nd, possibly 3rd choice or worse could be sent out on loan. If that happens I think that would be terrible after making his Premier League breakthrough as an impressive 19yo with raw but clear talent.
It would also send a bad signal to the other Academy players that even someone as good as Scarles at his age making decent performances at a high level, you're still likely to be sent out on loan starting the process all over again.
- Full Claret Jacket
- Posts: 281
- Location: Fortunes always hiding.....
- Old WHO Number: 209345
- Has liked: 26 times
- Been liked: 45 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
I think Scales will develop better not being under pressure of having to be consistent as young players rarely are. Diouf looked nervous and tentative last night but give him a chance to bed into the team, get used to the levels and what the manager wants.
-
- Posts: 1852
- Old WHO Number: 33051
- Has liked: 160 times
- Been liked: 329 times
-
- Posts: 472
- Old WHO Number: 212132
- Has liked: 25 times
- Been liked: 66 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
THUNDERCLINT wrote: ↑27 Jul 2025, 07:43 Had a perfectly good academy kid ready to go and Cock Piss drops 20m on a left back we didn't need when cash is scarce.
Unless there's a massive improvement on that performance expect Scarles to start the season.
Once the shrooms wear off, you will realise this was a stupid thread.
-
- Posts: 322
- Old WHO Number: 22726
- Has liked: 75 times
- Been liked: 68 times
Re: Tragic Diouf v Scarles
after one start in a friendly? this post really reeks of desperation to be the new board cսnt