Amazon Search and Bookmark
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!

Who has a better body of work

Forum area for all things that are non-football.
Forum rules
Whilst 'off-topic' means all non-football topics can be discussed. This is not a free for all. Rights to this area of the forum aren't implicit, and illegal, defamator, spammy or absuive topics will be removed, with the protagonist's sanctioned.
Post Reply
Nutsin
Posts: 2239
Old WHO Number: 274983
Has liked: 105 times
Been liked: 191 times

Who has a better body of work

Post Nutsin »

"Pacino, Scarface, Devils advocate, Glengarry Glenross, scent of a woman, Branco etc Deniro Taxi Driver, Once upon a time in America, Goodfellas Casino, midnight Run etc Who has the edge? And Who has a better body of work than these two?"
Nagel
Posts: 482
Old WHO Number: 11802

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Nagel »

"De Niro's best work in the 70s and 80s surpasses Pacino's for me. That said, De Niro became really bland when he hit middle age while Pacino at least learned to ham it up a little. Both of them went on a real downward trajectory though, with probably only a handful of decent films between them in the last 25 years."
User avatar
Takashi Miike
Posts: 3035
Old WHO Number: 233644
Has liked: 642 times
Been liked: 945 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Takashi Miike »

"clint eastwood, for me."
Oh dear
Posts: 53
Old WHO Number: 21613

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Oh dear »

and Richard Burton got to fuck Elizabeth Taylor.................
Oh dear
Posts: 53
Old WHO Number: 21613

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Oh dear »

"I'm going for Robert de Niro. As good as Al Pacino is the first thing you see when he acts is Al Pacino, then you see the part that he is playing. With Robert de Niro you see the part he is playing and then you recognise Robert de Niro. Not that either will give one single fuck what I think. Personally i think Richard Burton could have been better than both of them, but he was a piss head."
Far Cough
Posts: 2593
Old WHO Number: 34087
Been liked: 1 time

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Far Cough »

I like Hanks but does he have to be in every fucking film especially the ones that need a hero.
Far Cough
Posts: 2593
Old WHO Number: 34087
Been liked: 1 time

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Far Cough »

"Both are very good and both have range but just a personal opinion, it's Fugeddaboutit."
zico
Posts: 4071
Old WHO Number: 10629
Has liked: 257 times
Been liked: 165 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post zico »

I'd go with Manuel on this one. Both have done some brilliant films but in recent years also have done some turkeys. Most disappointing of all was when they collaborated again with the dreadful Righteous Kill. After Heat you hoped for a little more. I think many an actor from the golden age of Hollywood could be in comparison but out of those still living again as Manuel said Hanks ranks up there for me and you can't leave out old Clint Eastwood. Not as good an actor but has a body of work as both an actor and director that is impressive.
Fauxstralian
Posts: 2675
Old WHO Number: 321173
Has liked: 42 times
Been liked: 263 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Fauxstralian »

"Have I said I don’t get Tom Hanks AT ALL Greatest body of work in a short period before his death at 42 …. John Cazale In a 6 year period Godfather ,The Conversation ,Godfather 2 , Dog Day Afternoon & The Deer Hunter"
Fauxstralian
Posts: 2675
Old WHO Number: 321173
Has liked: 42 times
Been liked: 263 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Fauxstralian »

Pacino’s list has to include Godfather 2 (ditto for DeNiro) & Dog Day Afternoon I would lean slightly to Pacino for variety of characters
Fauxstralian
Posts: 2675
Old WHO Number: 321173
Has liked: 42 times
Been liked: 263 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Fauxstralian »

Pacino’s list has to include Godfather 2 (ditto for DeNiro) & Dog Day Afternoon I would lean slightly to Pacino for variety of characters
User avatar
Manuel
Posts: 4111
Location: The Very Far East
Old WHO Number: 300109
Has liked: 138 times
Been liked: 439 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Manuel »

"I don't think it's a yes or no answer, personal taste etc and both have had 50 year careers and done many things, and you have missed out some good films from both of them. Dog day afternoon, Carlito's Way, A Bronx tale, Casino, Cape fear, Serpico and The Godfather. One thing though, De Niro proved he could turn his hand to comedy, Meet the Fuckers etc, where Pacino has never done any serious comedy. As for your last question, hard to think of many others, maybe Tom Hanks."
Nutsin
Posts: 2239
Old WHO Number: 274983
Has liked: 105 times
Been liked: 191 times

Re: Who has a better body of work

Post Nutsin »

Brasco* fucking phone
Post Reply