Maverick180180 wrote: ↑27 Feb 2025, 12:54
stubbo wrote: ↑27 Feb 2025, 11:27
Personally I don't want to see a Back 4. Potter has always (pretty much) favoured a back 3 with aggressive wing backs, and no reason that shouldn't continue.
We look more secure with a Back 3 and have the personel to make it work...and in reality, the 'In Posession' shape in a back 3 is no different to a back 4....3-2-2-3. The debate is whether your wing backs in a Back 3 are able to offer suitable attacking contribution to not just be seen as 'defenders getting forwards'.
The debate for me is more about midfield composition...as one of the nerds channels was saying....we lack an effective two-man pivot, as no combination of two really gives us a complete unit (in the way that Alvarez + JWP + Soucek does).
To play Ferguson, either one of them has to drop, or you have to ask Scarles and AWB to drop in as a centre back to get the 3-2-2-3 shape in posession when the other side is pushing forwards.
I'd have a go without Soucek, but I can see the argument for keeping things the same.
fair point you make
but I do feel that every time we’ve played with 4 at the back this season, the problem hasn’t been the formation but rather the players selected to do it
I think the Villa cup game is an example of us playing with 4 at the back with the strongest line up available and was working really well until the injuries kicked in, in that game
but we haven’t tried that since
instead it’s only been tried with players playing out of position or dross like Rodriguez brought back into the side
Just an opinion of course, but I'd say that game was a really good example of how Potter likes to play 3 at the back (and that it was 3 at the back).
Summerville basically operated as wing back, AWB as Right centre back, Scarles as Left wing back. Out of possession you could see AWB tucked in as a third centre back with Summerville tasked with covering the flank.
In posession, Summerville was high, and AWB had licence to push wide and support high (as Todibo did at the weekend too).
That's pretty much how it went at Brighton too, with a traditional winger (Solly March) playing as wing back.