AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!
The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Forum rules
Whilst 'off-topic' means all non-football topics can be discussed. This is not a free for all. Rights to this area of the forum aren't implicit, and illegal, defamator, spammy or absuive topics will be removed, with the protagonist's sanctioned.
Whilst 'off-topic' means all non-football topics can be discussed. This is not a free for all. Rights to this area of the forum aren't implicit, and illegal, defamator, spammy or absuive topics will be removed, with the protagonist's sanctioned.
-
- Posts: 675
- Old WHO Number: 304394
- Has liked: 20 times
- Been liked: 73 times
The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
There. Resident WHO political commentators and gurus can knock yourselves out in here and conduct your endless bickering. All other threads will be locked.
-
- Posts: 526
- Old WHO Number: 18101
- Has liked: 124 times
- Been liked: 68 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Hammer I am" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:50I've watched the whole thing, I'm not sure how you can seriously defend their behaviour and he somehow deserved being treated like that.
I would be interested in hearing the specifics you are refering to, especially from the first 40 mins or so.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:39Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:10 Anyway Zelensky is toast, which is a good thing. He is the last person you want to try and negotiate with Putin.
Get him out, bring in a peace agreement and start rebuilding what’s left.
You can expect the MAGA movement to continue to slowly spread across Europe with added US pressure on the left wing Bureaucracy which is the EU.
Personally I’d hate to see the good people of the U K suffer while the US has its Golden age.What do you think this golden age will look like?
America first Goose. Smaller Gov’t lower taxes, pro growth policy, strong leadership, common sense policies, deregulation, greater transparency, end of woke, Globalism movement reduction in members and influence, less crime, safer streets, No wars! Lower inflation, Fair trade, healthier food supply And I do expect to see the US debt reduce but that will take a minute.
-
- Posts: 281
- Old WHO Number: 22726
- Has liked: 68 times
- Been liked: 59 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:39Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:10 Anyway Zelensky is toast, which is a good thing. He is the last person you want to try and negotiate with Putin.
Get him out, bring in a peace agreement and start rebuilding what’s left.
You can expect the MAGA movement to continue to slowly spread across Europe with added US pressure on the left wing Bureaucracy which is the EU.
Personally I’d hate to see the good people of the U K suffer while the US has its Golden age.What do you think this golden age will look like?
Something like Rodney's grown up Damien dream I imagine 
-
- Posts: 281
- Old WHO Number: 22726
- Has liked: 68 times
- Been liked: 59 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
ironsofcanada wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:47Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:29I must be slow tonight because I still don't get the second part. obviously he's made comments in public but that wasn't person on person negotiation (diplomacy if you will!)
Zelensky rose to the bait on what seemed to be an orchestrated ambush designed to humiliate him.
The political theatre we watched and more subtly in the 40 minutes before (I watched the whole thing, not just the theatre parts) Zelensky was trying to negotiate, change the deal, do diplomacy, whatever you want to call it, in front of the cameras.
It was not behind closed doors...completely contradictory to what you said you wanted.
Your last sentence is a parrotting of the neo-con war hawks I have heard since. It fantastical rubbish with some of the nastiest of backing.
Explain this "orchestrated ambush." Zelensky has a number of opportunities to negotiate and sign a deal in the last weeks and days. The Trump admin wanted it done long ago.
Zelensky insisted he go to the White House. So you are supposed to have an intro press conference, hash out the details - behind closed doors - and then sign the deal, cameras , fancy dinner etc. If you think he was justfied in negotiating in front of the press (though you say opposite) he is not being ambushed. If anyone was surprised it was Trump and Vance, if you watch the whole thing.
I've watched the whole thing, I'm not sure how you can seriously defend their behaviour and he somehow deserved being treated like that. It's like Trump saying Ukraine started the war 
I wonder if you going to slowly fade into the background as Trump gets more and more unhinged going forward. I bet Argentina is looking on in interest
I wonder if you going to slowly fade into the background as Trump gets more and more unhinged going forward. I bet Argentina is looking on in interest
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:10 Anyway Zelensky is toast, which is a good thing. He is the last person you want to try and negotiate with Putin.
Get him out, bring in a peace agreement and start rebuilding what’s left.
You can expect the MAGA movement to continue to slowly spread across Europe with added US pressure on the left wing Bureaucracy which is the EU.
Personally I’d hate to see the good people of the U K suffer while the US has its Golden age.
What do you think this golden age will look like?
-
- Posts: 281
- Old WHO Number: 22726
- Has liked: 68 times
- Been liked: 59 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin,
The increased British funding will be coming from frozen Russian assets so no we're not going to feel the pinch personally as a result. How poetic
The increased British funding will be coming from frozen Russian assets so no we're not going to feel the pinch personally as a result. How poetic
- SurfaceAgentX2Zero
- Posts: 630
- Old WHO Number: 214126
- Has liked: 87 times
- Been liked: 146 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
BillyJenningsBoots wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 20:25Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:16BillyJenningsBoots wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:58Are you saying those aren’t the facts. You only need google it to find the truth. Oh hang on why would you want to that!?Oh you want me to google what a left wing rag has apparently fact checked? How do they fact check the treasury payment system? Why was it only left wing rags getting all this funding? You want me to trust the fact checking of the liberal media ffs? Sorry but they’ve been caught in way too many lies for me to take their fact checking seriously.Is Politico a left wing rag... thought it was a Centrist digital news site.
It's an anti-Semitic and pro-Palestine news site for sure.
- BillyJenningsBoots
- Posts: 940
- Old WHO Number: 33164
- Has liked: 296 times
- Been liked: 82 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:16BillyJenningsBoots wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:58Are you saying those aren’t the facts. You only need google it to find the truth. Oh hang on why would you want to that!?Oh you want me to google what a left wing rag has apparently fact checked? How do they fact check the treasury payment system? Why was it only left wing rags getting all this funding? You want me to trust the fact checking of the liberal media ffs? Sorry but they’ve been caught in way too many lies for me to take their fact checking seriously.
Is Politico a left wing rag... thought it was a Centrist digital news site. Its only a problem due to them trying to link Trump to Putin. No wonder Trump wants to discredit them.
Leta face it everythings left wing compared to Trumps ethos!
Leta face it everythings left wing compared to Trumps ethos!
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Anyway Zelensky is toast, which is a good thing. He is the last person you want to try and negotiate with Putin.
Get him out, bring in a peace agreement and start rebuilding what’s left.
You can expect the MAGA movement to continue to slowly spread across Europe with added US pressure on the left wing Bureaucracy which is the EU.
Personally I’d hate to see the good people of the U K suffer while the US has its Golden age.
Get him out, bring in a peace agreement and start rebuilding what’s left.
You can expect the MAGA movement to continue to slowly spread across Europe with added US pressure on the left wing Bureaucracy which is the EU.
Personally I’d hate to see the good people of the U K suffer while the US has its Golden age.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:34Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:25Thin Ice? Trump recognizes we have too much debt, which is why we have DOGE and which is why he wants an end to the war ffs! Isn’t that obvious?
if you think the B of E has anywhere near the influence and power and control as the Federal Reserve you are sorely Mistaken.
But as I said, if you are happy with additional cuts in spending or Having to deal with an increase in taxation which includes inflation and Interest rates then go for it.
The interest on your national debt last year was $1.1tr.
Thats just the interest.
How much do you think DOGE is saving you this year?
You keep talking about cuts & increased taxes but neither is actually happening. Cuts in foreign aid are absolutely fine with me, I’m happy for that money to go on defence spending.
No idea how much DOGE will end up saving the US Taxpayer. To be honest I doubt it will reduce the deficit but I do expect the money to be used to encourage economic growth and will increase GDP.
You can go to DOGE.GOV and it lists all the savings so far and it shows receipts. A bit more legitimate than a CNN fact check.
You can go to DOGE.GOV and it lists all the savings so far and it shows receipts. A bit more legitimate than a CNN fact check.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:36You honestly think UK can and should match US pound for pound in matters like this?? There's a reason why every joint operation involving money is done on a percentage of GDP since the beginning of time. You really haven't thought that through have you
No, I don’t mate! But we’re out now, your choice if you want to help fill the void. But like I’ve been trying to explain to Goose it will hurt the British people if they do.
Thanks for making my point for me! U reading this Goose?
Thanks for making my point for me! U reading this Goose?
- Nurse Ratched
- Posts: 998
- Old WHO Number: 18642
- Has liked: 398 times
- Been liked: 397 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
F 129 Row66" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:38 Political question: On the Labour front bench there are Rachel Reeves and Angela Raynor, The Conservatives have Kemi Badenoch and Pritti Patel. Place them in the order you would.
Finally, a man with the right political instincts.
-
- Posts: 526
- Old WHO Number: 18101
- Has liked: 124 times
- Been liked: 68 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:29I must be slow tonight because I still don't get the second part. obviously he's made comments in public but that wasn't person on person negotiation (diplomacy if you will!)
Zelensky rose to the bait on what seemed to be an orchestrated ambush designed to humiliate him.
The political theatre we watched and more subtly in the 40 minutes before (I watched the whole thing, not just the theatre parts) Zelensky was trying to negotiate, change the deal, do diplomacy, whatever you want to call it, in front of the cameras.
It was not behind closed doors...completely contradictory to what you said you wanted.
Your last sentence is a parrotting of the neo-con war hawks I have heard since. It fantastical rubbish with some of the nastiest of backing.
Explain this "orchestrated ambush." Zelensky has a number of opportunities to negotiate and sign a deal in the last weeks and days. The Trump admin wanted it done long ago.
Zelensky insisted he go to the White House. So you are supposed to have an intro press conference, hash out the details - behind closed doors - and then sign the deal, cameras , fancy dinner etc. If you think he was justfied in negotiating in front of the press (though you say opposite) he is not being ambushed. If anyone was surprised it was Trump and Vance, if you watch the whole thing.
Last edited by ironsofcanada on 01 Mar 2025, 19:55, edited 6 times in total.
-
- Posts: 440
- Has liked: 231 times
- Been liked: 256 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Political question: On the Labour front bench there are Rachel Reeves and Angela Raynor, The Conservatives have Kemi Badenoch and Pritti Patel. Place them in the order you would.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:30goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:13Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:31Now let’s look at your world Goose. The USA has provided over $300 billion to the Ukraine in all aid, weapons, money etc: Which also includes money for social programs too. Zelensky reckons they haven’t received half of that amount, what a surprise we have Billions missing and unaccounted for.
Trump is cutting off the funding, if he does there is a huge void to fill.
The UK’s GDP is approx $3.3 trillion
Debt is $2.8 trillion
96% of GDP, according to Keynesian economics this amount of Debt to GDP is inflationary.
The country currently runs a budget deficit of $107 billion annually.
So fiscal policy won’t be easy or popular.
Monetary policy won’t be cheap, with the Benchmark “Bank Rate “ at 4%
Now the B of E could print the money and carry the debt on its balance sheet but that’s inflationary too, I’m seeing your current Inflation rate sits at 3%, in fact it just jumped in January.
So we will see how long the appetite of these European Governments lasts before they figure out that throwing all this money at a problem that can be possibly solved with diplomacy is the wrong thing to do.
Zelensky signing the mineral agreement with USA provides Ukraine with a US backstop that he doesn’t currently have, strengthening Ukraines position in any negotiations with Putin. Currently Zelensky doesn’t even have that. The man is toast, he just fucked up in a major way.
Personally I hope the UK sides with Trump for the sake of my Dad and my siblings that are still in the UK. But he won’t. And the war will drag on and you’ll feel the pinch in your pocket, more lives lost.
And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional.Uk has given 0.9% of GDP to Ukraine while the US has only given 0.5%. So please stop pretending their not paying their fair share.
if you wanna start pointing fingers about national debt you’re on very thin ice.Hmmmmn 0.5% of $27 trillion is a lot more than 0.9% of $3 trillion. Not sure what your point is, bottom line is your 0.9% is about to go up and ours is about to go down.Good eh!
You honestly think UK can and should match US pound for pound in matters like this?? There's a reason why every joint operation involving money is done on a percentage of GDP since the beginning of time. You really haven't thought that through have you
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:25goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:13Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:31Now let’s look at your world Goose. The USA has provided over $300 billion to the Ukraine in all aid, weapons, money etc: Which also includes money for social programs too. Zelensky reckons they haven’t received half of that amount, what a surprise we have Billions missing and unaccounted for.
Trump is cutting off the funding, if he does there is a huge void to fill.
The UK’s GDP is approx $3.3 trillion
Debt is $2.8 trillion
96% of GDP, according to Keynesian economics this amount of Debt to GDP is inflationary.
The country currently runs a budget deficit of $107 billion annually.
So fiscal policy won’t be easy or popular.
Monetary policy won’t be cheap, with the Benchmark “Bank Rate “ at 4%
Now the B of E could print the money and carry the debt on its balance sheet but that’s inflationary too, I’m seeing your current Inflation rate sits at 3%, in fact it just jumped in January.
So we will see how long the appetite of these European Governments lasts before they figure out that throwing all this money at a problem that can be possibly solved with diplomacy is the wrong thing to do.
Zelensky signing the mineral agreement with USA provides Ukraine with a US backstop that he doesn’t currently have, strengthening Ukraines position in any negotiations with Putin. Currently Zelensky doesn’t even have that. The man is toast, he just fucked up in a major way.
Personally I hope the UK sides with Trump for the sake of my Dad and my siblings that are still in the UK. But he won’t. And the war will drag on and you’ll feel the pinch in your pocket, more lives lost.
And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional.Uk has given 0.9% of GDP to Ukraine while the US has only given 0.5%. So please stop pretending their not paying their fair share.
if you wanna start pointing fingers about national debt you’re on very thin ice.Thin Ice? Trump recognizes we have too much debt, which is why we have DOGE and which is why he wants an end to the war ffs! Isn’t that obvious?
if you think the B of E has anywhere near the influence and power and control as the Federal Reserve you are sorely Mistaken.
But as I said, if you are happy with additional cuts in spending or Having to deal with an increase in taxation which includes inflation and Interest rates then go for it.
The interest on your national debt last year was $1.1tr.
Thats just the interest.
How much do you think DOGE is saving you this year?
You keep talking about cuts & increased taxes but neither is actually happening. Cuts in foreign aid are absolutely fine with me, I’m happy for that money to go on defence spending.
Thats just the interest.
How much do you think DOGE is saving you this year?
You keep talking about cuts & increased taxes but neither is actually happening. Cuts in foreign aid are absolutely fine with me, I’m happy for that money to go on defence spending.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:13Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:31Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:05So are you saying that the UK foreign aid program is as corrupt as the USA’s? Because some of the shit we were paying for was outrageous and some was blatant corruption, like funding several of big the liberal media outlets such as the BBC and Politico, making sure they were bought and paid for for example.Now let’s look at your world Goose. The USA has provided over $300 billion to the Ukraine in all aid, weapons, money etc: Which also includes money for social programs too. Zelensky reckons they haven’t received half of that amount, what a surprise we have Billions missing and unaccounted for.
Trump is cutting off the funding, if he does there is a huge void to fill.
The UK’s GDP is approx $3.3 trillion
Debt is $2.8 trillion
96% of GDP, according to Keynesian economics this amount of Debt to GDP is inflationary.
The country currently runs a budget deficit of $107 billion annually.
So fiscal policy won’t be easy or popular.
Monetary policy won’t be cheap, with the Benchmark “Bank Rate “ at 4%
Now the B of E could print the money and carry the debt on its balance sheet but that’s inflationary too, I’m seeing your current Inflation rate sits at 3%, in fact it just jumped in January.
So we will see how long the appetite of these European Governments lasts before they figure out that throwing all this money at a problem that can be possibly solved with diplomacy is the wrong thing to do.
Zelensky signing the mineral agreement with USA provides Ukraine with a US backstop that he doesn’t currently have, strengthening Ukraines position in any negotiations with Putin. Currently Zelensky doesn’t even have that. The man is toast, he just fucked up in a major way.
Personally I hope the UK sides with Trump for the sake of my Dad and my siblings that are still in the UK. But he won’t. And the war will drag on and you’ll feel the pinch in your pocket, more lives lost.
And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional.Uk has given 0.9% of GDP to Ukraine while the US has only given 0.5%. So please stop pretending their not paying their fair share.
if you wanna start pointing fingers about national debt you’re on very thin ice.
Hmmmmn 0.5% of $27 trillion is a lot more than 0.9% of $3 trillion. Not sure what your point is, bottom line is your 0.9% is about to go up and ours is about to go down.Good eh!
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
ironsofcanada wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:16Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:12What in your mind is a contradiction there? Yes I said diplomacy should take place behind closed doors not live on tv, I also said I can't speak from a position of fact what has or hasn't happened behind closed doors before this, where's the contradiction?
Like I also said and correct me if I'm wrong but Zelensky said yes he's open to a deal but only under certain conditions, like guaranteed security from the US, a sensible position considering he's already been invaded twice. If I were him I'd be sceptical that the Trump and Putin haven't already agreed to carve up Ukraine amongst themselves in their little peace negotiation that he wasn't invited toYou are saying it should have been behind closed doors but he was justified in doing what he did which was...not doing it behind closed doors.
Not sure how clear a contradiction you need.
I must be slow tonight because I still don't get the second part. obviously he's made comments in public but that wasn't person on person negotiation (diplomacy if you will!)
Zelensky rose to the bait on what seemed to be an orchestrated ambush designed to humiliate him.
Zelensky rose to the bait on what seemed to be an orchestrated ambush designed to humiliate him.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
goose wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:13Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:31Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:05So are you saying that the UK foreign aid program is as corrupt as the USA’s? Because some of the shit we were paying for was outrageous and some was blatant corruption, like funding several of big the liberal media outlets such as the BBC and Politico, making sure they were bought and paid for for example.Now let’s look at your world Goose. The USA has provided over $300 billion to the Ukraine in all aid, weapons, money etc: Which also includes money for social programs too. Zelensky reckons they haven’t received half of that amount, what a surprise we have Billions missing and unaccounted for.
Trump is cutting off the funding, if he does there is a huge void to fill.
The UK’s GDP is approx $3.3 trillion
Debt is $2.8 trillion
96% of GDP, according to Keynesian economics this amount of Debt to GDP is inflationary.
The country currently runs a budget deficit of $107 billion annually.
So fiscal policy won’t be easy or popular.
Monetary policy won’t be cheap, with the Benchmark “Bank Rate “ at 4%
Now the B of E could print the money and carry the debt on its balance sheet but that’s inflationary too, I’m seeing your current Inflation rate sits at 3%, in fact it just jumped in January.
So we will see how long the appetite of these European Governments lasts before they figure out that throwing all this money at a problem that can be possibly solved with diplomacy is the wrong thing to do.
Zelensky signing the mineral agreement with USA provides Ukraine with a US backstop that he doesn’t currently have, strengthening Ukraines position in any negotiations with Putin. Currently Zelensky doesn’t even have that. The man is toast, he just fucked up in a major way.
Personally I hope the UK sides with Trump for the sake of my Dad and my siblings that are still in the UK. But he won’t. And the war will drag on and you’ll feel the pinch in your pocket, more lives lost.
And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional.Uk has given 0.9% of GDP to Ukraine while the US has only given 0.5%. So please stop pretending their not paying their fair share.
if you wanna start pointing fingers about national debt you’re on very thin ice.
Thin Ice? Trump recognizes we have too much debt, which is why we have DOGE and which is why he wants an end to the war ffs! Isn’t that obvious?
if you think the B of E has anywhere near the influence and power and control as the Federal Reserve you are sorely Mistaken.
But as I said, if you are happy with additional cuts in spending or Having to deal with an increase in taxation which includes inflation and Interest rates then go for it.
if you think the B of E has anywhere near the influence and power and control as the Federal Reserve you are sorely Mistaken.
But as I said, if you are happy with additional cuts in spending or Having to deal with an increase in taxation which includes inflation and Interest rates then go for it.
-
- Posts: 526
- Old WHO Number: 18101
- Has liked: 124 times
- Been liked: 68 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:12What in your mind is a contradiction there? Yes I said diplomacy should take place behind closed doors not live on tv, I also said I can't speak from a position of fact what has or hasn't happened behind closed doors before this, where's the contradiction?
Like I also said and correct me if I'm wrong but Zelensky said yes he's open to a deal but only under certain conditions, like guaranteed security from the US, a sensible position considering he's already been invaded twice. If I were him I'd be sceptical that the Trump and Putin haven't already agreed to carve up Ukraine amongst themselves in their little peace negotiation that he wasn't invited to
You are saying it should have been behind closed doors but he was justified in doing what he did which was...not doing it behind closed doors.
Not sure how clear a contradiction you need.
Not sure how clear a contradiction you need.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
BillyJenningsBoots wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:58Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:42BillyJenningsBoots wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:36Are you sure you dont want to fact check that Nutsin. The Politico payments from USAID was a false claim as they were subscriptions to Politico products and services.
The payments were not to the BBC but to Media Action a BBC charity that is totally separate to BBC News.
The charity, which supports press freedom around the world, recently received a $750,000 donation from Jack Dorsey, co-founder of the now Musk-owned social media platform X.Who fact checked that Billy, Politico or the BBC?Are you saying those aren’t the facts. You only need google it to find the truth. Oh hang on why would you want to that!?
Oh you want me to google what a left wing rag has apparently fact checked? How do they fact check the treasury payment system? Why was it only left wing rags getting all this funding? You want me to trust the fact checking of the liberal media ffs? Sorry but they’ve been caught in way too many lies for me to take their fact checking seriously.
- BillyJenningsBoots
- Posts: 940
- Old WHO Number: 33164
- Has liked: 296 times
- Been liked: 82 times
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 19:06Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:45Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:31Now let’s look at your world Goose. The USA has provided over $300 billion to the Ukraine in all aid, weapons, money etc: Which also includes money for social programs too. Zelensky reckons they haven’t received half of that amount, what a surprise we have Billions missing and unaccounted for.
Trump is cutting off the funding, if he does there is a huge void to fill.
The UK’s GDP is approx $3.3 trillion
Debt is $2.8 trillion
96% of GDP, according to Keynesian economics this amount of Debt to GDP is inflationary.
The country currently runs a budget deficit of $107 billion annually.
So fiscal policy won’t be easy or popular.
Monetary policy won’t be cheap, with the Benchmark “Bank Rate “ at 4%
Now the B of E could print the money and carry the debt on its balance sheet but that’s inflationary too, I’m seeing your current Inflation rate sits at 3%, in fact it just jumped in January.
So we will see how long the appetite of these European Governments lasts before they figure out that throwing all this money at a problem that can be possibly solved with diplomacy is the wrong thing to do.
Zelensky signing the mineral agreement with USA provides Ukraine with a US backstop that he doesn’t currently have, strengthening Ukraines position in any negotiations with Putin. Currently Zelensky doesn’t even have that. The man is toast, he just fucked up in a major way.
Personally I hope the UK sides with Trump for the sake of my Dad and my siblings that are still in the UK. But he won’t. And the war will drag on and you’ll feel the pinch in your pocket, more lives lost.
And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional."And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional."
Mate I know Americans aren't great at geography but have you consulted a map? Annexing Ukraine would achieve putting Nato on his border when previously it wasn'tMate, The part of Ukraine that Putin eventually walks away with will provide a buffer zone for Russia.
Not ideal but Putin would rather have Ukraine border NATO rather than Russia, even the part he takes. Dont be so sure that Ukraine joins NATO.
Lets face NATO is now probably out of the question as Trump will veto any application. I think it needs a unanimous vote.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:31Nutsin wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 18:05So are you saying that the UK foreign aid program is as corrupt as the USA’s? Because some of the shit we were paying for was outrageous and some was blatant corruption, like funding several of big the liberal media outlets such as the BBC and Politico, making sure they were bought and paid for for example.Now let’s look at your world Goose. The USA has provided over $300 billion to the Ukraine in all aid, weapons, money etc: Which also includes money for social programs too. Zelensky reckons they haven’t received half of that amount, what a surprise we have Billions missing and unaccounted for.
Trump is cutting off the funding, if he does there is a huge void to fill.
The UK’s GDP is approx $3.3 trillion
Debt is $2.8 trillion
96% of GDP, according to Keynesian economics this amount of Debt to GDP is inflationary.
The country currently runs a budget deficit of $107 billion annually.
So fiscal policy won’t be easy or popular.
Monetary policy won’t be cheap, with the Benchmark “Bank Rate “ at 4%
Now the B of E could print the money and carry the debt on its balance sheet but that’s inflationary too, I’m seeing your current Inflation rate sits at 3%, in fact it just jumped in January.
So we will see how long the appetite of these European Governments lasts before they figure out that throwing all this money at a problem that can be possibly solved with diplomacy is the wrong thing to do.
Zelensky signing the mineral agreement with USA provides Ukraine with a US backstop that he doesn’t currently have, strengthening Ukraines position in any negotiations with Putin. Currently Zelensky doesn’t even have that. The man is toast, he just fucked up in a major way.
Personally I hope the UK sides with Trump for the sake of my Dad and my siblings that are still in the UK. But he won’t. And the war will drag on and you’ll feel the pinch in your pocket, more lives lost.
And if anyone thinks Putin doesn’t have a right to be concerned with hav NATO on his border then you’re a delusional.
Uk has given 0.9% of GDP to Ukraine while the US has only given 0.5%. So please stop pretending their not paying their fair share.
if you wanna start pointing fingers about national debt you’re on very thin ice.
if you wanna start pointing fingers about national debt you’re on very thin ice.
Last edited by goose on 01 Mar 2025, 19:16, edited 1 time in total.
Re: The Official Politics Thread (enter at your own risk)
ironsofcanada wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 17:41Mr Anon" wrote: ↑01 Mar 2025, 17:25
The only point I can see you made is you see Zelensky as scuppering deals being made behind closed doors, I can't really debate what happens behind closed doors and nor can you surely. What I can do is comment and criticise what happens on the public domain.
As far as I can see Zelensky stated he was open to a deal but only if US confirmed their security, seems reasonable to meYou literally said "Behind closed doors would be a good fucking start," as something better that could be done. Which is it?
So your position is you can agree to something, say in the press multiple times you are going sign the deal and then change that in a formality press conference and expect not to be treated rudely?
What in your mind is a contradiction there? Yes I said diplomacy should take place behind closed doors not live on tv, I also said I can't speak from a position of fact what has or hasn't happened behind closed doors before this, where's the contradiction?
Like I also said and correct me if I'm wrong but Zelensky said yes he's open to a deal but only under certain conditions, like guaranteed security from the US, a sensible position considering he's already been invaded twice. If I were him I'd be sceptical that the Trump and Putin haven't already agreed to carve up Ukraine amongst themselves in their little peace negotiation that he wasn't invited to
Like I also said and correct me if I'm wrong but Zelensky said yes he's open to a deal but only under certain conditions, like guaranteed security from the US, a sensible position considering he's already been invaded twice. If I were him I'd be sceptical that the Trump and Putin haven't already agreed to carve up Ukraine amongst themselves in their little peace negotiation that he wasn't invited to