Amazon Search and Bookmark
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!

If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

West Ham Online's Football Forum
Post Reply
Barty888
Posts: 268
Has liked: 17 times
Been liked: 49 times

If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Barty888 »

25% win percentage 

Clueless today
Council Scum
Posts: 562
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 1 time
Been liked: 200 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Council Scum »

Jean-Luc Paul Goddard" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:55
Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:36
Lampard lost 15 of 84, Potter 11 of 31.

Lampard finished 4th and FA Cup final
Potter 11th 
Lampard lost 23 out of 84 in his first spell, then 8 out of 11 after Potter. His first spell was during the Abramovic regime, so his 4th place finish and FA cup runner up were pretty mediocre for the club at the time. They won the Europa League the season before he came and the Champions League the season he got sacked.

To be fair he has done a very good job at Coventry in the Championship. Taking over a club in 17th in late November and leading them to 5th is great, very similar to what Carrick did at Boro when he started, although he didn't progress from there at all. 
He did well at Derby to get the job...

He was a complete novice at Chelsea and his first season was decent for a new manager, he then didn't get the signings he wanted (Rice being the main one) but the ones the club wanted and it went wrong from there.

He was shit at Everton 

Doing well at Coventry, he's not second rate. 

Not saying I want him, but he's doing well as a young manager. 
Jean-Luc Paul Goddard
Posts: 425
Has liked: 44 times
Been liked: 188 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Jean-Luc Paul Goddard »

Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:36
Lampard lost 15 of 84, Potter 11 of 31.

Lampard finished 4th and FA Cup final
Potter 11th 
Lampard lost 23 out of 84 in his first spell, then 8 out of 11 after Potter. His first spell was during the Abramovic regime, so his 4th place finish and FA cup runner up were pretty mediocre for the club at the time. They won the Europa League the season before he came and the Champions League the season he got sacked.

To be fair he has done a very good job at Coventry in the Championship. Taking over a club in 17th in late November and leading them to 5th is great, very similar to what Carrick did at Boro when he started, although he didn't progress from there at all. 
User avatar
Lee Trundle
Posts: 3750
Old WHO Number: 33318
Been liked: 720 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Lee Trundle »

Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:52
Lee Trundle" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:50
Mad Ferret" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:47


 
Here you go Chutney son.  I've made the important letter in my sentence all big and bold for you.
But that was as a caretaker when they were all over the place. 

So what makes him second rate? 
 
 
We're all over the place.  It's exactly the same situation.  What makes you think Lampard would come in and do better than Potter with the same tools?

Chelsea made same mistake in appointing fatty after Potter.  1 win in 11.  I don't want us doing the same, and there's absolutely no romance in him coming back to us, like there was with him and Chelsea.
User avatar
Mad Ferret
Posts: 1694
Has liked: 176 times
Been liked: 286 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Mad Ferret »

What you on about Trundle?

You seem to be getting all confused about who replied to you.
Council Scum
Posts: 562
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 1 time
Been liked: 200 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Council Scum »

Lee Trundle" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:50
Mad Ferret" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:47
He made Potter look like a good manager, after he replaced him at Chelsea.
Here you go Chutney son.  I've made the important letter in my sentence all big and bold for you.
But that was as a caretaker when they were all over the place. 

So what makes him second rate? 
User avatar
Lee Trundle
Posts: 3750
Old WHO Number: 33318
Been liked: 720 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Lee Trundle »

Mad Ferret" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:47
He made Potter look like a good manager, after he replaced him at Chelsea.
Here you go Chutney son.  I've made the important letter in my sentence all big and bold for you.
User avatar
Mad Ferret
Posts: 1694
Has liked: 176 times
Been liked: 286 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Mad Ferret »

Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:36
Lee Trundle" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:55
Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:44
What makes him a second rate manager? 
He made Potter look like a good manager, after he replaced him at Chelsea.
Lampard lost 15 of 84, Potter 11 of 31.

Lampard finished 4th and FA Cup final
Potter 11th 
With a transfer ban.
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3422
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 152 times
Been liked: 863 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post El Scorchio »

Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:36
Lee Trundle" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:55
Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:44
What makes him a second rate manager? 
He made Potter look like a good manager, after he replaced him at Chelsea.
Lampard lost 15 of 84, Potter 11 of 31.

Lampard finished 4th and FA Cup final
Potter 11th 
On 6 April 2023, Lampard returned to Chelsea by being appointed as caretaker manager until the end of the 2022–23 season, following the dismissal of Graham Potter.[sup][295][/sup] Chelsea's form dropped after Lampard took over and produced a first bottom-half finish since 1996 and a record low tally of points and goals scored in the Premier League era.[sup][296][/sup] In terms of winning percentage, Lampard also had the worst record (9%) among every Chelsea manager who had led 3 or more matches, achieving just one win in his 11 matches in charge.
Council Scum
Posts: 562
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 1 time
Been liked: 200 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Council Scum »

Lee Trundle" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:55
Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:44
What makes him a second rate manager? 
He made Potter look like a good manager, after he replaced him at Chelsea.
Lampard lost 15 of 84, Potter 11 of 31.

Lampard finished 4th and FA Cup final
Potter 11th 
Come On You Irons
Posts: 839
Old WHO Number: 304394
Has liked: 35 times
Been liked: 141 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Come On You Irons »

I would be amazed if Lampard would ever contemplate managing us. He is a Chelsea man through and through now and some of our moronic 20 stone, pot bellied supporters still take pleasure from calling him "Big fat Frank".

Not that I would want him here anyway. He's a shit top flight manager. Much like Parker his management level is the Championship.

It will be Nuno or Dyche replacing pathetic Potter when he eventually goes. I wouldn't rule out Steve Cooper either, given Sullivan's MO.
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3422
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 152 times
Been liked: 863 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post El Scorchio »

threesixty wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:24
El Scorchio" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:10
threesixty wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 11:57 After not bothering to contact Jose I understand that this club will always strive to appoint the worst possible person they can find out of a set of available options. It’s just what they do. It will never be the obvious choice. It will always be a somewhat perverse decision that only they could justify in their heads. It’s what they enjoy. 

so Nuno is out of the question because it’s just too sensible a choice for them. 

I think it has to be someone who has in the past had success but is clearly not wanted by any other club for pretty obvious reasons. Sullivan likes a sort of “fixer upper”, I feel like he wants to say I saw the potential when others didn’t. And it has to be a yes man. Someone that will never embarrass him. And obviously out of work. 




 
Nah it will 100% be Nuno if he's still out of work if/when Potter goes. I wouldn't be surprised at all if Sullivan has already said to him 'Just hold on until Sunday.'
 
I hope so. 
I think he's exactly what Sullivan would want, because he thinks we will find it more palatable than Dyche. Which to be fair is true.
threesixty
Posts: 897
Old WHO Number: 14819
Has liked: 117 times
Been liked: 232 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post threesixty »

El Scorchio" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 12:10
threesixty wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 11:57 After not bothering to contact Jose I understand that this club will always strive to appoint the worst possible person they can find out of a set of available options. It’s just what they do. It will never be the obvious choice. It will always be a somewhat perverse decision that only they could justify in their heads. It’s what they enjoy. 

so Nuno is out of the question because it’s just too sensible a choice for them. 

I think it has to be someone who has in the past had success but is clearly not wanted by any other club for pretty obvious reasons. Sullivan likes a sort of “fixer upper”, I feel like he wants to say I saw the potential when others didn’t. And it has to be a yes man. Someone that will never embarrass him. And obviously out of work. 



 
Nah it will 100% be Nuno if he's still out of work if/when Potter goes. I wouldn't be surprised at all if Sullivan has already said to him 'Just hold on until Sunday.'
 
 
I hope so. 
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3422
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 152 times
Been liked: 863 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post El Scorchio »

threesixty wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 11:57 After not bothering to contact Jose I understand that this club will always strive to appoint the worst possible person they can find out of a set of available options. It’s just what they do. It will never be the obvious choice. It will always be a somewhat perverse decision that only they could justify in their heads. It’s what they enjoy. 

so Nuno is out of the question because it’s just too sensible a choice for them. 

I think it has to be someone who has in the past had success but is clearly not wanted by any other club for pretty obvious reasons. Sullivan likes a sort of “fixer upper”, I feel like he wants to say I saw the potential when others didn’t. And it has to be a yes man. Someone that will never embarrass him. And obviously out of work. 

 
Nah it will 100% be Nuno if he's still out of work if/when Potter goes. I wouldn't be surprised at all if Sullivan has already said to him 'Just hold on until Sunday.'
Pub Bigot
Posts: 730
Old WHO Number: 255703
Has liked: 889 times
Been liked: 335 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Pub Bigot »

Frank Jr may have been one of us once, but he is no longer and will be a Chelsea fan. 

I could well imagine some of us could put water under the bridge, but he’s not the answer to our issues, not least because he’d have to manage a circus above him, and I don’t believe he’d be cutout to manage the team. If we struggled in the way the team are now, the vitriol towards Frank would be significant. 

I don’t like him personally based on what I’ve seen and read, I don’t want him and I thankfully don’t think it’s likely. 
threesixty
Posts: 897
Old WHO Number: 14819
Has liked: 117 times
Been liked: 232 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post threesixty »

After not bothering to contact Jose I understand that this club will always strive to appoint the worst possible person they can find out of a set of available options. It’s just what they do. It will never be the obvious choice. It will always be a somewhat perverse decision that only they could justify in their heads. It’s what they enjoy. 

so Nuno is out of the question because it’s just too sensible a choice for them. 

I think it has to be someone who has in the past had success but is clearly not wanted by any other club for pretty obvious reasons. Sullivan likes a sort of “fixer upper”, I feel like he wants to say I saw the potential when others didn’t. And it has to be a yes man. Someone that will never embarrass him. And obviously out of work. 
 
Massive Attack
Posts: 5719
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 3317 times
Been liked: 1647 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Massive Attack »

As much as it would have been a good fit for us at this moment in time, Sullivan was never going to hire someone as dangerous to his regime as Mourinho. 
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3422
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 152 times
Been liked: 863 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post El Scorchio »

Was never coming to us in a million years anyway. Sullivan will be doing cartwheels if Jose is off the market because he's far too much of a coward to employ him.
violator
Posts: 713
Old WHO Number: 15360
Has liked: 215 times
Been liked: 205 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post violator »

Mourinho off to Benfica according to the Beeb
User avatar
Lee Trundle
Posts: 3750
Old WHO Number: 33318
Been liked: 720 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Lee Trundle »

Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:44
What makes him a second rate manager? 
He made Potter look like a good manager, after he replaced him at Chelsea.
Council Scum
Posts: 562
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 1 time
Been liked: 200 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Council Scum »

El Scorchio" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:33
Massive Attack" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:16 The Fat cսnt can get fucked. It would be the icing on the cake for Sullivan to do it though to perfectly sum up his reign at the Club, so wouldn't put it past him doing it out of spite of the fans.
 
I genuinely wouldn't put it past Sullivan to do it out of ignorance or spite. Not to mention yet again piss poor judgement of talent.

The fat cսnt is an absolute second rate manager and would be absolutely hate from the moment he rocked up to the moment he got sacked with the club likely in the championship- his level.

Surely fatty would have the sense not to take it even if Sullivan tried to offer it to him?
What makes him a second rate manager? 
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3422
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 152 times
Been liked: 863 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post El Scorchio »

Massive Attack" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:16 The Fat cսnt can get fucked. It would be the icing on the cake for Sullivan to do it though to perfectly sum up his reign at the Club, so wouldn't put it past him doing it out of spite of the fans.
 
 
I genuinely wouldn't put it past Sullivan to do it out of ignorance or spite. Not to mention yet again piss poor judgement of talent.

The fat cսnt is an absolute second rate manager and would be absolutely hate from the moment he rocked up to the moment he got sacked with the club likely in the championship- his level.

Surely fatty would have the sense not to take it even if Sullivan tried to offer it to him?
Vexed
Posts: 1119
Old WHO Number: 240179
Has liked: 3 times
Been liked: 264 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Vexed »

Dick Shaftsbury" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 08:40 Mourinho has just agreed to join Benfica. So that's that idea out of the window.
Aaargh, the dream is dead. It would have been such a spectacular train wreck too. 
User avatar
Lee Trundle
Posts: 3750
Old WHO Number: 33318
Been liked: 720 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post Lee Trundle »

Council Scum" wrote: 17 Sep 2025, 10:13
You all need to remember, regardless of what happened at Chelsea, his family (and him believe it or not) are huge West Ham fans. 
 
 
So is John Terry's.

Let get him in as assistant manager along with the fat cսnt.
simons
Posts: 128
Has liked: 80 times
Been liked: 75 times

Re: If Potter would get sacked who would you want IN to replace him?

Post simons »

If Mourinho was a player, Sullivan would be all over this.

Past it, been there and done it, living on previous glories. Potential to get fans off their seats and engaged again.  Big name still in football, who will generate extra interest in the club.

This gives me a very slim hope that it may actually happen. 
 
Post Reply