Official Transfer Window Thread | I'll try and stay current with signings and rumours.
Could be The Scarf's last chance to prove his worth as well as make-or-break for Lopetegui who needs to shuffle the back to suit what we're trying to do more.
Rumoured In:
Ewan Ferguson, ST (Brighton)
Carney Chukwumeka, CM (Chelsea)
Carlos Soler, CM (PSG, Loan to Perm)
Emmanuel Latte Lath, ST (Middlesbrough)
Shea Charles, CM (Southampton)
Ezekiel Banzuzi, CM (Leuven)
Arthur Carbral, ST (Benfica)
Taiwo Awoniyi, ST (Forest)
Igor Jesus, ST (Botofogo)
Marcus Rashford, FW (Man Utd)
Jonathan David, ST (Lille)
Evann Guessand, ST, (Nice)
Randal Kolo Muani, ST, (PSG)
Kieran Dewsbury-Hall , CM, (Chelsea)
André Silva, ST, (RB Leipzig)
Elye Wahi, ST, (Marseille)
Kristjan Asllani, CM, (Inter)
Rodrigo Muniz, ST, (Fulham)
Callum Wilson, ST, (Newcastle)
Ansu Fati, AM, (Barcelona)
Angel Gomes, CM, (Lille, pre-contract)
Adam Webster, CB, (Brighton)
Brian Brobbey, ST, (Ajax)
Ricardo Pepi, ST, (PSV)
James McAtee, MF, (Man City)
Yuri Alberto, ST, (Corinthians)
Tyler Morton, DM, (Liverpool)
Rumoured Out:
Kudus (Liverpool, Newcastle, Arsenal)
Fullkrüg (Juventus)
Rodriguez (Betis)
Alvarez (Monaco)
Emerson (Juventus)
Luis Guilherme (Al Hilal)
Confirmed In:
Josh Landers (!), ST (Hibernian)
James Ward-Prowse, MF, (Nottigham Forest | Return from loan)
Evan Ferguson, ST, (Brighton, Loan...no option/obligation to buy)
Sir Alf" wrote: ↑26 Jan 2025, 10:27
Story from Italy, Todibo loan to buy to Juventus. Surely just speculation ?
Ok he got an injury but he is a perfect player for Potter’s system imo. We would be insane to move him on after 6 months and only a handful of games.
Unless Sullivan is doing a revisionist thimg and removing all traces of Steidten in his scapegoating campaign?
“The Sullivan Effect” in full flow now he’s back in charge of recruitment. A 76 year old freak wreaking havoc.
Just embarrassing if true, unless he’s flat refusing to come back (I wouldn’t actually blame him) or Potter has genuinely said he doesn’t want him. But no way is a guy who wants to play three centre backs wanting to lose one of only three he has on the books- his best one at that. Or perhaps he’s just been very problematic behind the scenes.
impossible to know really, if there’s any truth to this.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 26 Jan 2025, 10:27
by Sir Alf
Story from Italy, Todibo loan to buy to Juventus. Surely just speculation ?
Ok he got an injury but he is a perfect player for Potter’s system imo. We would be insane to move him on after 6 months and only a handful of games.
Unless Sullivan is doing a revisionist thimg and removing all traces of Steidten in his scapegoating campaign?
“The Sullivan Effect” in full flow now he’s back in charge of recruitment. A 76 year old freak wreaking havoc.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 26 Jan 2025, 09:31
by nychammer
El Scorchio" wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 21:44
It's ridiculous when you look at it. Zero coherent strategy or plan.
Come on now, it’s not like we’ve had half a season to figure it out
RootsRadical wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 20:39
Duran - Fulkrug = Chalk & Cheese
Duran, Brobbey - Andre Silver = Chalk & Cheese.
We never learn!
I’m going to guess Brobbey = Potter and Silva = Sullivan.
Well, Sullivan and Salthouse
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 21:44
by El Scorchio
It's ridiculous when you look at it. Zero coherent strategy or plan.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 21:03
by RootsRadical
Yep.
Add to that...
Antonio - Scamacca
Antonio - Ings
It's just illogical and foolish as we (Sullivan)keep repeating the same mistakes which has left us with no strikers and cost us tens of millions in wasted fees and wages.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 20:56
by El Scorchio
RootsRadical wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 20:39
Duran - Fulkrug = Chalk & Cheese
Duran, Brobbey - Andre Silver = Chalk & Cheese.
We never learn!
I’m going to guess Brobbey = Potter and Silva = Sullivan.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 20:39
by RootsRadical
Duran - Fulkrug = Chalk & Cheese
Duran, Brobbey - Andre Silver = Chalk & Cheese.
We never learn!
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 19:57
by Ron Eff
Frank De Boer is saying Brobbey is a bad signing so I’m now all in given his Premier League management credentials having been sacked with a 0% record and 0 goals scored.
The last time I checked he wasn’t our manager so why would I be praising him? Potter is our manager so he will get my full support.
Seems a bit strange and illogical to steadfastly defend him in every way while he’s here to just change your mind and criticise his actions here once he’s gone is all.
Agreed but he obviously didn’t want either of those two players. One was here before he arrived and the other was so obviously bought in against his wishes. Neither were in any way had the attributes he wanted or needed. That’s not to say he shouldn’t have adapted for them but he never chose either. Give him someone with the attributes of Antonio or Arnie or the attributes he actually wants or needs for his system, and he will get a tune out of them.
PS I cannot believe I’ve just seen you criticise Moyes.
The last time I checked he wasn’t our manager so why would I be praising him? Potter is our manager so he will get my full support.
Seems a bit strange and illogical to steadfastly defend him in every way while he’s here to just change your mind and criticise his actions here once he’s gone is all.
Moyes record with expensive strikers is abysmal, he ruined the careers of Haller & Scamacca.
Agreed but he obviously didn’t want either of those two players. One was here before he arrived and the other was so obviously bought in against his wishes. Neither were in any way had the attributes he wanted or needed. That’s not to say he shouldn’t have adapted for them but he never chose either. Give him someone with the attributes of Antonio or Arnie or the attributes he actually wants or needs for his system, and he will get a tune out of them.
PS I cannot believe I’ve just seen you criticise Moyes.
The last time I checked he wasn’t our manager so why would I be praising him? Potter is our manager so he will get my full support.
Seems a bit strange and illogical to steadfastly defend him in every way while he’s here to just change your mind and criticise his actions here once he’s gone is all.
El Scorchio" wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 18:45
If they do, funny that the very first transfer window Moyes isn’t working under Sullivan, he signs a young promising striker with the right attributes like he never did here. Whereas we are still failing to, two managers on. Wonder what the common denominator could be there as if you ever needed any proof about why we can’t sign anyone.
Moyes 1 Sullivan 0. And I’m not even proud to say that.
Moyes record with expensive strikers is abysmal, he ruined the careers of Haller & Scamacca.
Agreed but he obviously didn’t want either of those two players. One was here before he arrived and the other was so obviously bought in against his wishes. Neither were in any way had the attributes he wanted or needed. That’s not to say he shouldn’t have adapted for them but he never chose either. Give him someone with the attributes of Antonio or Arnie or the attributes he actually wants or needs for his system, and he will get a tune out of them.
PS I cannot believe I’ve just seen you criticise Moyes.
The last time I checked he wasn’t our manager so why would I be praising him? Potter is our manager so he will get my full support.
El Scorchio" wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 18:45
If they do, funny that the very first transfer window Moyes isn’t working under Sullivan, he signs a young promising striker with the right attributes like he never did here. Whereas we are still failing to, two managers on. Wonder what the common denominator could be there as if you ever needed any proof about why we can’t sign anyone.
Moyes 1 Sullivan 0. And I’m not even proud to say that.
Moyes record with expensive strikers is abysmal, he ruined the careers of Haller & Scamacca.
Agreed but he obviously didn’t want either of those two players. One was here before he arrived and the other was so obviously bought in against his wishes. Neither were in any way had the attributes he wanted or needed. That’s not to say he shouldn’t have adapted for them but he never chose either. Give him someone with the attributes of Antonio or Arnie or the attributes he actually wants or needs for his system, and he will get a tune out of them.
PS I cannot believe I’ve just seen you criticise Moyes.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 18:48
by twoleftfeet
El Scorchio" wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 18:45
If they do, funny that the very first transfer window Moyes isn’t working under Sullivan, he signs a young promising striker with the right attributes like he never did here. Whereas we are still failing to, two managers on. Wonder what the common denominator could be there as if you ever needed any proof about why we can’t sign anyone.
Moyes 1 Sullivan 0. And I’m not even proud to say that.
Moyes record with expensive strikers is abysmal, he ruined the careers of Haller & Scamacca.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 18:45
by El Scorchio
If they do, funny that the very first transfer window Moyes isn’t working under Sullivan, he signs a young promising striker with the right attributes like he never did here. Whereas we are still failing to, two managers on. Wonder what the common denominator could be there as if you ever needed any proof about why we can’t sign anyone.
Moyes 1 Sullivan 0. And I’m not even proud to say that.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 18:37
by Mad Dog
Not gonna watch that clip, but wouldn't bet against sullivan fucking up the deal. Would you?
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 18:33
by twoleftfeet
stubbo wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 18:19
I haven't got the energy to summarise this but it's fucking Sullivan again. The man is a bonafide cսnt and needs dealing with by the fans. Absolute cսnt.
It’s Nick at C & B, don’t believe anything he says.
He changes his stories every 12 hours for click bait.
We will sign Brobbey.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 18:19
by stubbo
I haven't got the energy to summarise this but it's fucking Sullivan again. The man is a bonafide cսnt and needs dealing with by the fans. Absolute cսnt.
Brobbey is having a sub-par season by his own standards and wanted to leave in the Summer. There's been a managerial change to a manager that doesn't play so much to his strengths and prefers to play Weghorst. Ajax have a policy of cashing in on their best players at the peak of their value. So they have a young striker who doesn't want to be there having an off season after an exceptional one....they're just gambling that now is the moment to get their best return.
No guarantee he succeeds for us, but their allowing him to leave doesn't mean he's useless.
He may well turn out to be a perfect fit, i really hope so.
two questions for me are:
1. Is he better than Ings?
2. What is the deal structure?
answer to 1 is more than like. Two, I just hope we’re not locked into an expensive obligation for a short sighted solution.
Looks like it's a permanent but deferred because of PSR and how do you know we're not looking at it as the long term solution we want?
We’ve got about £145m of PSR headroom so I don’t know why we’d be deferring the transfer fee to the summer.
maybe he is the long term solution, but it doesn’t look or feel that way.
I will re-position it as no team in a top league will let their best players go.
Ajax will let this fella go for a reason.
Brobbey is having a sub-par season by his own standards and wanted to leave in the Summer. There's been a managerial change to a manager that doesn't play so much to his strengths and prefers to play Weghorst. Ajax have a policy of cashing in on their best players at the peak of their value. So they have a young striker who doesn't want to be there having an off season after an exceptional one....they're just gambling that now is the moment to get their best return.
No guarantee he succeeds for us, but their allowing him to leave doesn't mean he's useless.
He may well turn out to be a perfect fit, i really hope so.
two questions for me are:
1. Is he better than Ings?
2. What is the deal structure?
answer to 1 is more than like. Two, I just hope we’re not locked into an expensive obligation for a short sighted solution.
Looks like it's a permanent but deferred because of PSR and how do you know we're not looking at it as the long term solution we want?
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 11:43
by El Scorchio
We need a striker the same as we did in the summer when most on here were turning up their noses at Duran...
Bang on. No one is ever good enough. I’m sure some would moan if we signed Haaland and Salah.
Re: Official January '25 Transfer Window Thread
Posted: 25 Jan 2025, 11:36
by fraser
Steady wrote: ↑25 Jan 2025, 11:11
The fact Ajax are insisting it’s an obligation rather than option to buy says it all
Just says he's their player and they'll sell him on their terms.. We should do the same.
They turned down multiple bids in the summer, he's wanted out since then.
We need a striker the same as we did in the summer when most on here were turning up their noses at Duran...
Nobody knows how good or bad he will be, but he's the right profile unlike Ings or Fullkrug...
