Amazon Search and Bookmark
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!

Blur V Oasis

Forum area for all things that are non-football.
Forum rules
Whilst 'off-topic' means all non-football topics can be discussed. This is not a free for all. Rights to this area of the forum aren't implicit, and illegal, defamator, spammy or absuive topics will be removed, with the protagonist's sanctioned.
Post Reply
Central Park Man
Posts: 50
Has liked: 3 times
Been liked: 4 times

Oasis Blur V Oasis

Post Central Park Man »

For me Blur are streets ahead of them!
User avatar
mallard
Posts: 915
Old WHO Number: 14461
Has liked: 273 times
Been liked: 119 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post mallard »

Swiss. wrote: 26 Aug 2025, 10:36
Ron Eff" wrote: 25 Aug 2025, 21:56 I can’t think of another band who create the demand  Oasis do. That should answer the question.

Albarn’s also a Chelsea twat, so that doubles down on it. 
Just proves the majority of people are no taste sheep. The public wants what the public gets as Paul Weller would say. 


Speaking of Weller, he released some great solo albums during that era
Eerie Decent
Posts: 745
Has liked: 111 times
Been liked: 304 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Eerie Decent »

Don't think any of the bands were consistently brilliant, and I'm not an Oasis fanatic, but Definitely Maybe is up there with the best albums ever made. The rest of their stuff, big shrug from me.

Think Tank by Blur is a great album, as is Dog Man Star by Suede, Different Class by Pulp.

Can't say I'm that fussed by much else.
Council Scum
Posts: 488
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 1 time
Been liked: 171 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Council Scum »

Oasis basically became their own tribute band by the time the 90's ended. 

Blur constantly reinvented themselves over a long period. 

So talent wise, Blur. 

Oasis are basically the Billy Joel tribute in Step Brothers where he only plays 1980's Billy Joel. 
,
Posts: 1024
Has liked: 11 times
Been liked: 94 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post , »

I won’t give an opinion as to who is better but it really is a mad world where people pay hundreds of pounds to indulge in a mass singalong of tunes, much of them thirty years old, that are derivative of music from thirty years prior.
Swiss.
Posts: 1556
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 233 times
Been liked: 275 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Swiss. »

Ron Eff" wrote: 25 Aug 2025, 21:56 I can’t think of another band who create the demand  Oasis do. That should answer the question.

Albarn’s also a Chelsea twat, so that doubles down on it. 
Just proves the majority of people are no taste sheep. The public wants what the public gets as Paul Weller would say. 
Ron Eff
Posts: 612
Old WHO Number: 229621
Has liked: 19 times
Been liked: 154 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Ron Eff »

I can’t think of another band who create the demand  Oasis do. That should answer the question.

Albarn’s also a Chelsea twat, so that doubles down on it. 
Vexed
Posts: 1034
Old WHO Number: 240179
Has liked: 3 times
Been liked: 205 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Vexed »

the coming of gary" wrote: 25 Aug 2025, 16:49 Another good Britpop band were GENE - did a nice cover of the Jam's 'Wasteland'

I liked SLEEPER too

Both bands are set to play in London in October  (separately)
.
I saw Sleeper recently, they were never the most intense band but unsurprisingly they are even less so now. It was nostalgic but a little disappointing. Singer still looks pretty decent considering she must be pushing sixty now.
I have also been tricked into catching Gene on this tour, I'm not expecting much and I was never much of a fan, but it's a few beers innit. 
the coming of gary
Posts: 315
Old WHO Number: 14200
Has liked: 57 times
Been liked: 75 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post the coming of gary »

Another good Britpop band were GENE - did a nice cover of the Jam's 'Wasteland'

I liked SLEEPER too

Both bands are set to play in London in October  (separately)
.
Pshyco scored all 4
Posts: 240
Has liked: 312 times
Been liked: 91 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Pshyco scored all 4 »

I preferred pulp and the verve over both . 
Swiss.
Posts: 1556
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 233 times
Been liked: 275 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Swiss. »

And this:

Swiss.
Posts: 1556
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 233 times
Been liked: 275 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Swiss. »

In the same era neither did a song as good as this:



 
honky cat
Posts: 841
Has liked: 501 times
Been liked: 322 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post honky cat »

Music like coffee and wine, is all good but largely comes down to personal tastes. I prefer Blur, more depth and lyrically interesting to me but they could still rustle up a sing along banger like Song 2, parklife.
I admire albarn for moving with the times and like gorillaz a lot. I know they (blur) reunited for a few gigs but like Depeche Mode have managed to avoid the nostalgia market.

Oasis best album, definitely maybe - and after what's the story it all went downhill for me. Blur kept improving and moving forward imo.









 
yngwies Cat
Posts: 418
Old WHO Number: 17468
Has liked: 118 times
Been liked: 91 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post yngwies Cat »

Mansum..now they were the cream of the top
yngwies Cat
Posts: 418
Old WHO Number: 17468
Has liked: 118 times
Been liked: 91 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post yngwies Cat »

I always found the singer from Blurs voice fuckin annoying, however, loved the song Universal and my best mates dad sold his Fender Telcaster to Graham Coxon (he didn't have a clue who he was. 

Where's 97mde...or what ever the who poster was.

Oasis, gobby macs .

Both bands to be apluded, as we're all them lot.

Not really my bag, but at least they played.





 
User avatar
Takashi Miike
Posts: 3144
Old WHO Number: 233644
Has liked: 684 times
Been liked: 1037 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Takashi Miike »

violator wrote: 22 Aug 2025, 19:21 Pulp, Charlatans and Mansun shat on both of them 
saw the Charlatans a lot back when Rob Collins & Jon were still alive
User avatar
zebthecat
Posts: 1657
Old WHO Number: 16911
Has liked: 190 times
Been liked: 154 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post zebthecat »

I wasn't a massive fan of either of them but Blur did some more interesting.
Bumped into Damon Albarn at the bar at a Cardiacs gig which was cool.
violator
Posts: 657
Old WHO Number: 15360
Has liked: 195 times
Been liked: 169 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post violator »

Pulp, Charlatans and Mansun shat on both of them 
only1billybonds
Posts: 2111
Old WHO Number: 217810
Has liked: 441 times
Been liked: 627 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post only1billybonds »

Oasis gave brilliant interviews in the Melody Maker and NME back then, really enjoyable reads. The fact that they portrayed themselves as naughty boys from a council estate definitely added to their appeal. Best interviewees though were without a doubt the Happy Mondays, being part of their set up must have been an insane ride. 
As for the music, I was always more of a Pulp/Verve fan rather than Oasis/Blur bit gun to head,I'd say Oasis did more for me for me at that time.
User avatar
Takashi Miike
Posts: 3144
Old WHO Number: 233644
Has liked: 684 times
Been liked: 1037 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Takashi Miike »



User avatar
Takashi Miike
Posts: 3144
Old WHO Number: 233644
Has liked: 684 times
Been liked: 1037 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Takashi Miike »

loved Blur mainly because of Coxon. Oasis in those first few years were great, so many excellent b-sides, then understandably lost the plot once the money poured in. those two in interviews back then were comedy gold 😂
User avatar
Bungo
Posts: 518
Old WHO Number: 228443
Has liked: 149 times
Been liked: 112 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Bungo »

Bowener wrote: 22 Aug 2025, 16:29
I came here for this! Father Damo - what a rebel!🤣
Bowener
Posts: 39
Has liked: 21 times
Been liked: 17 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Bowener »

User avatar
RootsRadical
Posts: 887
Old WHO Number: 321614
Has liked: 37 times
Been liked: 149 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post RootsRadical »

Met Blur & Albarn particularly in their prime.
Used to see his cousin for about 6 months & met them after a gig. Stayed up all night drinking with them, Damon was actually alright, down to earth, just sat with me & his cousin & her brother chatting & drinking. The rest of them were a bit annoying doing the drunk rock n roll thing all night for the muso journalists.
This was our first date. Met her a few days earlier and she asked me if I wanted to go to the gig and then meet them after as Damon was her cousin. She was gorgeous & I was into Blur at the time so obviously agreed to meet her, though not sure she would even turn up or be his cousin.
She turns up and sure enough we walk straight in on his guest list & it's all true.

Blur v Oasis was a 90s version of Mods v Rockers. Always been more of a Mod a preferred Blur.
Eerie Decent
Posts: 745
Has liked: 111 times
Been liked: 304 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post Eerie Decent »

Central Park Man" wrote: 22 Aug 2025, 15:55
oioi wrote: 22 Aug 2025, 15:09 C&P from NME

Blur might’ve won the 1995 chart battle, but Albarn reckons the Gallagher brothers won the war, admitting: “Well, it was obvious, wasn’t it? I think we can officially say that Oasis won the battle, the war, the campaign, everything.” The Gorillaz artist continued: “They are the winners. They take first place. In the face of such overwhelming evidence, I am happy to accept and concede defeat. It’s their summer and God bless them. I hope everyone has a wonderful time.

Personally, I can't stand Oasis.
I guess it really does come down to personal choice.
Thanks for that, Nietzsche.
User avatar
wils
Posts: 957
Location: London
Old WHO Number: 276191
Has liked: 153 times
Been liked: 304 times

Re: Blur V Oasis

Post wils »

Central Park Man" wrote: 22 Aug 2025, 15:54
wils wrote: 22 Aug 2025, 15:49 Think we will all agree that Spurs are shit though wouldn't we Central Park Man?
I'm lost?
 
 
Image
Post Reply