Also, Potter leads Sweden to the WC.
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!
Eye ties
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 8772
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 5092 times
- Been liked: 2739 times
Re: Eye ties
Gordon also won a Cup not so long ago with Newcastle and been banging them in the Champions League this season 10 in 12. Definite over Rashford for me.
- El Scorchio
- Posts: 4642
- Old WHO Number: 227648
- Has liked: 285 times
- Been liked: 1390 times
Re: Eye ties
Rossal wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 15:12El Scorchio" wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 14:58It's really not very dissimilar to Rashford's with the caveat Rashford plays for Barcelona with a spell at a relatively high flying Villa after being frozen out for being a cock at Man U and Gordon only plays for Newcastle but hasn't caused any issues at all. Gordon is younger and more reliable.
There's not loads between them but I'd rather have Gordon, especially with a less reliable player on the right flank.I disagree, Rashford seemed to find something at Villa last season and carried that form into Barcelona where he has played well this year off the left. Gordon was struggling massively till a move up top where his form and scoring started to pick up. I'd rather have Rogers on the left than Gordon.
Rashford has scored ten league goals in two seasons with only 4 in 24 appearances for Barcelona playing farmers most weeks. He got two for Villa. Gordon has 12 in the same amount of time playing for a comparable PL side. Again it's worth noting Rashford has only played for other teams after being a troublemaker under two separate managers at Man U.
I'd definitely start Gordon. Rashford at his best is great but you never know what you're going to get which is the trouble, and he's been nowhere near the player of 2022 since then.
I'd definitely start Gordon. Rashford at his best is great but you never know what you're going to get which is the trouble, and he's been nowhere near the player of 2022 since then.
- Manuel
- Posts: 4811
- Location: The Very Far East
- Old WHO Number: 300109
- Has liked: 233 times
- Been liked: 643 times
Re: Eye ties
El Scorchio" wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 14:58It's really not very dissimilar to Rashford's with the caveat Rashford plays for Barcelona with a spell at a relatively high flying Villa after being frozen out for being a cock at Man U and Gordon only plays for Newcastle but hasn't caused any issues at all. Gordon is younger and more reliable.
There's not loads between them but I'd rather have Gordon, especially with a less reliable player on the right flank.
I disagree, Rashford seemed to find something at Villa last season and carried that form into Barcelona where he has played well this year off the left. Gordon was struggling massively till a move up top where his form and scoring started to pick up. I'd rather have Rogers on the left than Gordon.
- El Scorchio
- Posts: 4642
- Old WHO Number: 227648
- Has liked: 285 times
- Been liked: 1390 times
Re: Eye ties
It's really not very dissimilar to Rashford's with the caveat Rashford plays for Barcelona with a spell at a relatively high flying Villa after being frozen out for being a cock at Man U and Gordon only plays for Newcastle but hasn't caused any issues at all. Gordon is younger and more reliable.
There's not loads between them but I'd rather have Gordon, especially with a less reliable player on the right flank.
There's not loads between them but I'd rather have Gordon, especially with a less reliable player on the right flank.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 8772
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 5092 times
- Been liked: 2739 times
Re: Eye ties
If you look at it, quite a few players have been out of form but little other options. Pickford, Kane, O'Reilly, Rogers have hit regular form but many including Bowen have been off it. Sometimes it's a case of hoping players find that form at the right time and play through it and there's a few that appear to be in that situation all at once.
Re: Eye ties
I was happy about all the results last night except maybe a Denmark losing as I have some Danish ancestry, However I did work in Prague for 15 months and lived in Stockholm for 3 years and have family links to Turkey so all good.
Can't stand the Italians.
Can't stand the Italians.
- El Scorchio
- Posts: 4642
- Old WHO Number: 227648
- Has liked: 285 times
- Been liked: 1390 times
Re: Eye ties
Pickford
toss up between Hall and O'Reilly. I think we are weak here and this position will be our weak link
Stones
Guehi
James
Rice
Bellingham
Anderson if Bellingham is the 10, Palmer if Bellingham is the 8. JB is a cսnt but he's better than Rogers.
Gordon
Kane
Saka (yes, over Bowen reluctantly. Bowen won't go hiding but Saka just has that little bit more pace and fear factor for defenders and with the security of Gordon on the other side it's needed. If Rashford started I'd be very tempted with Bowen on the right.)
toss up between Hall and O'Reilly. I think we are weak here and this position will be our weak link
Stones
Guehi
James
Rice
Bellingham
Anderson if Bellingham is the 10, Palmer if Bellingham is the 8. JB is a cսnt but he's better than Rogers.
Gordon
Kane
Saka (yes, over Bowen reluctantly. Bowen won't go hiding but Saka just has that little bit more pace and fear factor for defenders and with the security of Gordon on the other side it's needed. If Rashford started I'd be very tempted with Bowen on the right.)
-
happygilmore
- Posts: 960
- Old WHO Number: 34065
- Has liked: 71 times
- Been liked: 76 times
Re: Eye ties
the coming of gary" wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 09:50 Last night was a laugh, but If i'm honest i think all previous winners should be given automatic qualification.
its only eight places out of forty - eight these days. And its better if Brazil Italy, Argentina are all there
Anyone who disagrees can watch Bosnia v Qatar on June 24th !!
.
Expanded WC, you get hammered home and away by Norway, then an easy play off route via Northern Ireland and Bosnia and you fuck it up, you don't deserve to be there.
It's not the fucking Eurovision!
I'll probably only watch the Q/Fs onwards with any serious interest. I'm sure the Yanks will ham it up
It's not the fucking Eurovision!
I'll probably only watch the Q/Fs onwards with any serious interest. I'm sure the Yanks will ham it up
Re: Eye ties
Come On You Irons" wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 11:48 My starting XI for the first England game at the WC would be:
Pickford
Livramento
Stones
Maguire
Shaw
Rice
Anderson
Palmer
Bowen
Kane
Gordon
That team would do well.
So, "Come on you whites"?? Interesting
Re: Eye ties
Pickford
James Konsa Guehi Hall
Rice Anderson
Palmer Bellingham Rashford
Kane
that would be my thinking, would require Palmer to pick up some form though for Chelsea. Maguire may start over Konsa aswell as such a threat at set pieces. Rodgers, Wharton, O' Reilly could also force themselves into the 11 between now and end of season for me.
That RW spot is probably the most open, although would be surprising if Saka doesnt start against Croatia.
James Konsa Guehi Hall
Rice Anderson
Palmer Bellingham Rashford
Kane
that would be my thinking, would require Palmer to pick up some form though for Chelsea. Maguire may start over Konsa aswell as such a threat at set pieces. Rodgers, Wharton, O' Reilly could also force themselves into the 11 between now and end of season for me.
That RW spot is probably the most open, although would be surprising if Saka doesnt start against Croatia.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 8772
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 5092 times
- Been liked: 2739 times
Re: Eye ties
I was in two minds about Saka initially going with Bowen but found both in indifferent form this season and Saka does have the experience in Tournaments that made me think I'd start him ahead of him. I'd be fine with Bowen starting though, yet cannot see Tuchel taking him the way he thinks of him as an afterthought.
-
Council Scum
- Posts: 822
- Old WHO Number: 19891
- Has liked: 2 times
- Been liked: 320 times
Re: Eye ties
Massive Attack" wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 11:54 If all fit my best starting England XI would be..
Pickford
James Stones Guehi Hall
Rice Bellingham
Saka Palmer Gordon
Kane
Wouldn't have Saka anywhere near the team, rest looks ok though.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 8772
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 5092 times
- Been liked: 2739 times
Re: Eye ties
If all fit my best starting England XI would be..
Pickford
James Stones Guehi Hall
Rice Bellingham
Saka Palmer Gordon
Kane
Pickford
James Stones Guehi Hall
Rice Bellingham
Saka Palmer Gordon
Kane
-
Come On You Irons
- Posts: 1561
- Old WHO Number: 304394
- Has liked: 107 times
- Been liked: 367 times
Re: Eye ties
My starting XI for the first England game at the WC would be:
Pickford
Livramento
Stones
Maguire
Shaw
Rice
Anderson
Palmer
Bowen
Kane
Gordon
That team would do well.
Pickford
Livramento
Stones
Maguire
Shaw
Rice
Anderson
Palmer
Bowen
Kane
Gordon
That team would do well.
- El Scorchio
- Posts: 4642
- Old WHO Number: 227648
- Has liked: 285 times
- Been liked: 1390 times
Re: Eye ties
Yup it's got to be Watkins. Who else is there? DCL for a big physical alternative to throw on if we need a change of plan or a goal? If you give Watkins chances, he will finish them. Rashford will go as he's seen as versatile and can play 2-3 positions. Trouble is he's either a match winner or he's shit. England have too many of those in contention to start games. You can't have 2-3 boom or bust players in the same side at this level because they will let you down in key moments. You need a guaranteed level of performance which the likes of Rashford or Madueke don't give you. If you're playing a Madueke you need a Gordon on the other side rather than a Rashford, IMO.
It's a shame Bellingham is clearly an ego and a cսnt, really. I'd like him nailed on for the 10 or the 8 as he's clearly a better player than the rest of them. It's a shame to see such talent not playing.
It's a shame Bellingham is clearly an ego and a cսnt, really. I'd like him nailed on for the 10 or the 8 as he's clearly a better player than the rest of them. It's a shame to see such talent not playing.
- Tomshardware
- Posts: 1404
- Old WHO Number: 266280
- Has liked: 775 times
- Been liked: 350 times
Re: Eye ties
Agreed, Watkins is still a decent alternative and has proven he can score goals at that level. I'd pick him over Rashford.
Re: Eye ties
Without Kane up front there’s no purpose, May as well play Wilson then what he’s experimented with, whats Watkins done wrong, at least he’s a decent backup to Kane, who is not going to manage many 90 minutes in the summer heat.
- El Scorchio
- Posts: 4642
- Old WHO Number: 227648
- Has liked: 285 times
- Been liked: 1390 times
Re: Eye ties
Italy are a total basket case. Complete boom or bust with them. Still a crying shame we lost on pens to them in 2021. That really was a golden chance which we should have taken. Don't think that prick Saka has missed one since has he?
Glad to see our Czech mates qualified for the first time in 20 years
Glad to see our Czech mates qualified for the first time in 20 years
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 8772
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 5092 times
- Been liked: 2739 times
Re: Eye ties
Bosnia are ranked 65th in the World as well which rubs salt into injury. 
As for Japan (19th), they're actually a half decent side now these days with some quality that can do damage. Quality goal once Pamler gifted it to them in their half. We had many missing but still no excuse to lose and one to take on the chin.
As for Japan (19th), they're actually a half decent side now these days with some quality that can do damage. Quality goal once Pamler gifted it to them in their half. We had many missing but still no excuse to lose and one to take on the chin.
-
the coming of gary
- Posts: 459
- Old WHO Number: 14200
- Has liked: 138 times
- Been liked: 134 times
Re: Eye ties
Last night was a laugh, but If i'm honest i think all previous winners should be given automatic qualification.
its only eight places out of forty - eight these days. And its better if Brazil Italy, Argentina are all there
Anyone who disagrees can watch Bosnia v Qatar on June 24th !!
.
its only eight places out of forty - eight these days. And its better if Brazil Italy, Argentina are all there
Anyone who disagrees can watch Bosnia v Qatar on June 24th !!
.
Re: Eye ties
dealcanvey wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 07:50 Anyone watch England last night?
Tuchel getting on my nerves. Another manager trying to fit square pegs in round holes and re write football. Started 7 midfielders last night and looked disjointed.
Less confident for this tournament than I was with Southgate.
Agree with this. Most the players that started against Uruguay wouldn't be on the plane for the majority of fans. Last night Foden gets rewarded with a shit performance to start in the no 9. Rogers on the left was terrible, Palmer terrible.
Not having Tuchel at all, we were awful last night and I am not convinced the back 4 will keep the likes of Mbappe and Yamal quiet in the latter stages.
Not having Tuchel at all, we were awful last night and I am not convinced the back 4 will keep the likes of Mbappe and Yamal quiet in the latter stages.
- Manuel
- Posts: 4811
- Location: The Very Far East
- Old WHO Number: 300109
- Has liked: 233 times
- Been liked: 643 times
Re: Eye ties
I don't fancy this US world cup much and don't really rate England's chances. We do have some talent in midfield but the defense looks suspect and we're being told again today that we are heavily reliant on Kane up top while conveniently forgetting his mediocre performances in previous tournaments.
Fancy we might exit in the QF.
Fancy we might exit in the QF.
