AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!
VAR - What is it good for?
-
- Posts: 576
- Old WHO Number: 10365
- Has liked: 244 times
- Been liked: 94 times
-
- Posts: 1
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"I also thought a player couldn't be offside if the ball was played backwards, however nowhere in the laws of the game is this stipulated: https://www.thefa.com/football-rules-governance/lawsandrules/laws/football-11-11/law-11---offside 99% of the time a ball played backwards will be to someone who is behind the ball, but not in this case. As far as I can see the decision was correct, albeit an extremely tight call."
-
- Posts: 2116
- Old WHO Number: 10221
- Has liked: 142 times
- Been liked: 47 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
Gilmore Kane is behind the ball and player aswell. Shocker of a decision. Funny though.
-
- Posts: 892
- Old WHO Number: 34065
- Has liked: 48 times
- Been liked: 48 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"Pedro Incorrect, if the player receiving the ball is in front when the pass is made, he is offside, regardless of deflection."
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
In Portugal so watching watching with the Lisbon fans. Very funny but that is a shocking decision. Can’t be offside if ball goes backwards. Offside rule since 1257!
-
- Posts: 204
- Old WHO Number: 212340
- Has liked: 17 times
- Been liked: 21 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
I had a few quid on them when they went behind. There’s not many better ways to lose a bet.
-
- Posts: 892
- Old WHO Number: 34065
- Has liked: 48 times
- Been liked: 48 times
-
- Posts: 892
- Old WHO Number: 34065
- Has liked: 48 times
- Been liked: 48 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
Cunte is a horrible character Loved seeing him racing down the line celebrating only for a VAR and a red card for him. even if the goal being cancelled costs me a decision win on over 2.5 goals
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
Just nearly woke the kids up shouting with joy at that VAR decision. You love to see it. I don’t like to take pleasure from other peoples sorrow but when it’s Spurs that sentiment goes out the window.
-
- Posts: 2125
- Old WHO Number: 217810
- Has liked: 446 times
- Been liked: 646 times
-
- Posts: 204
- Old WHO Number: 212340
- Has liked: 17 times
- Been liked: 21 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"Haha, another excellent night for VAR in Haringey. Shocking, yet outstanding intervention."
- ray winstone
- Posts: 481
- Location: Utopia
- Old WHO Number: 33640
- Has liked: 43 times
- Been liked: 43 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
Just seen the challenge by Lerma on Shamacca. Not really sure why VAR didn’t intervene on that one?
-
- Posts: 1987
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
I would suggest that pre-VAR no-one would be talking about the Kehrer handball either. The whole ball brushing the arm scenario was something invented alongside the VAR implementation for whatever reason. Understandable that opposition fans might be complaining but any volleyball comarisons are a nonsensical exaggeration of what happened.
-
- Posts: 395
- Old WHO Number: 34559
- Has liked: 1 time
- Been liked: 46 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"the rule isn't great, but i don't think its particularly unclear. Our first goal was handball. By any measure or any definition of the rule. That VAR cannot intervene because of PHASES is a broad irrelevance - if the referee does his job and blows immediately for the obvious handball, no one is talking about it. It was just a poor refereeing decision. We'll take it, just as we have with all the others this season. Let's just not whine when some go against us."
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"VAR wasn’t the problem here. The handball rule is the problem. For the first goal, the hand was against his body, but he moved his arm and put the ball back in play as if he was playing volleyball. We obviously gained from the handball, and the rules should make it clear. For the penalty, that is handball all day long. He had his hands in the air and they gained the advantage. You just can’t put your arms in the air like that and expect not to give away a penalty. Lerma was also lucky to be on the pitch after his lunging, studs up challenge. VAR didn’t look at that, and no one is talking about it. But it goes against the narrative."
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"VAR wasn’t the problem here. The handball rule is the problem. For the first goal, the hand was against his body, but he moved his arm and put the ball back in play as if he was playing volleyball. We obviously gained from the handball, and the rules should make it clear. For the penalty, that is handball all day long. He had his hands in the air and they gained the advantage. You just can’t put your arms in the air like that and expect not to give away a penalty. Lerma was also lucky to be on the pitch after his lunging, studs up challenge. VAR didn’t look at that, and no one is talking about it. But it goes against the narrative."
- Manuel
- Posts: 4111
- Location: The Very Far East
- Old WHO Number: 300109
- Has liked: 137 times
- Been liked: 438 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"As I said yesterday and prior to that, the handball law is a total abomination now, it appears that no one knows what the fuck is going on, it's just pot luck if your side get a pen or get away with a pen. Zero consistency."
-
- Posts: 336
- Old WHO Number: 14384
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
Social media is AWASH with fans of other teams fuming saying how everything always gets given our way. Haha. YLTSI
- Lee Trundle
- Posts: 3556
- Old WHO Number: 33318
- Been liked: 629 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"Call me cynical, but I don't think we get either if those decisions given our way if we were playing a Sky 6 team instead of Bournemouth."
-
- Posts: 336
- Old WHO Number: 14384
-
- Posts: 323
- Old WHO Number: 22726
- Has liked: 76 times
- Been liked: 69 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"Was Mike Dean I believe, thanks Mike, you still owe is a few though"
-
- Posts: 44
- Old WHO Number: 218412
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"VAR is just utter bollocks. It's all over the place. Odd that we emerged on the right side for once. Enjoy it. Today was Bournemouth, not the bin dippers or the other lot next to them."
-
- Posts: 535
- Old WHO Number: 18101
- Has liked: 129 times
- Been liked: 69 times
Re: VAR - What is it good for?
"Ron Eff 1:17 Tue Oct 25 fraser 1:17 Tue Oct 25 Cheers gentleman. Every day is a school day, as they say."