Amazon Search and Bookmark
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!

Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

West Ham Online's Football Forum
Post Reply
User avatar
stubbo-admin
Posts: 1283
Old WHO Number: 12009
Has liked: 274 times
Been liked: 609 times

Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post stubbo-admin »


May as well get going with this since with Sullivan at the helm, season ticket renewals slow, and the football vacuum to commence, this will soon be all the "news" there is.

Can Potter and MacCauley pull multiple rabbits out of the hat, or will Sullivan 'try really hard' with all of them before grabbing a few aging bargains from Big Willie Salthouse?

Window this close season comes in two parts:

Part 1: 1st June to 10th June
Part 2: 16th June to 1st September

Rumoured Outs...most of the squad

Let the "Rumoured In's" commence. 

------------------------------------------------------------

Player | Position | Club | Fee (GBP)

Rumoured In
  1. Daniel Cummings | ST | Celtic
  2. Koni De Winter | CB | Genoa
  3. Morten Frendrup | DM | Genoa
  4. Richard Kone | ST | Wycombe
  5. Aaron Ramsdale | GK | Southampton
  6. Caiomin Kelleher | GK | Liverpool
  7. James Trafford | GK | Burnley
  8. Kyle Walker-Peters | FB | Free Agent
  9. Taylor Harwood-Bellis | CB | Southampton
  10. CJ Egan-Riley | CB | Free Agent
  11. Josh Brownhill | CM | Free Agent
  12. Albian Hajdari | CB | Lugano
  13. Lucas Høgsberg | CB | FC Nordsjælland
  14. Ardon Jashari | CM | Brugge
  15. Raphael Onyedika | CM | Brugge
  16. James McAtee | AM | Man City
  17. Mario Struykens | AM | Anderlecht
  18. Mathias Kvistgaarden | ST | Brondby
  19. Clement Bischoff | LB | Brondby
  20. Mika Biereth | FW | Monaco
  21. Barış Alper Yılmaz | AM | Galatasaray
  22. Evann Guessand | ST | Nice
  23. Lucas Stassin | ST | Saint Etienne
  24. Marcus Taverner | FW | Bournemouth
  25. Soungoutoo Magassa | CDM | Monaco
  26. Valentin Atangana | CM | Stade Reims
  27. Mads Hermansen | GK | Leicester City
  28. Hamza Igamane | ST | Rangers
  29. Yeremay | FW | Deportivo La Coruna
  30. Adama Bojang | ST | Reims
  31. Rocco Reitz | MF | Borussia Moenchengladbach
  32. Dominic Calvert-Lewin | ST | Free Agent
  33. El Hadji Malick Diouf | LB | SK Slavia Prague
  34. Oscar Mingueza | RB/MF | Celta Vigo
  35. Tyler Morton | CM | Liverpool
  36. Harvey Elliott | AM | Liverpool
  37. Zion Suzuki | GK | Parma
  38. John Victor | GK | Botofogo 
  39. Jacob Ramsey | MF | Villa
  40. Mateus Fernandes | CM | Southampton
  41. Nga Makou | CM | Lille
  42. Quinten Timber | CM
  43. Hayden Hackney | CM | Boro
  44. Yves Bissouma | CM | Spurs
Rumoured Out
  1. Nayef Aguerd | CB | Leverkusen, Marseile
  2. Maxel Cornet | FW | Genoa/Others
  3. Guido Rodriguez | DM | Betis/Espanyol
  4. Tomas Soucek | CM | Everton
  5. Michail Antonio | ST | Free Agent
  6. Mo Kudus | FW | Chelsea/Newcastle/Arsenal
  7. Lucas Paqueta | AM | Man City
  8. Andy Irving | CM | Celtic/Wrexham
  9. Emerson | LB | Marseille
Confirmed In
  1. Jean Clair Todibo | CB | Loan To Perm (32m)
  2. Daniel Cummings | ST | Celtic (Free Agent...Tribunal)
  3. El Hadji Malick Diouf | LWB | Slavia Prahia | 20m
  4. Kyle Walker-Peters | RWB | Free Agent
  5. C****m Wilson | ST | Free Agent
  6. Mads Hermansen | GK | Leicester (18m)
  7. Mateus Fernandes | CM | Southampton (38m + 4m)
  8. Soungoutoo Magassa | CDM | Monaco (17m)
  9. Igor Julio | CB | Brighton (Loan)

Confirmed Out
  1. Aaron Cresswell | LB | Free Agent | 0m
  2. Danny Ings | ST | Free Agent | 0m
  3. Vladimir Coufal | RB | Free Agent | 0m
  4. Lukusz Fabianski | GK | Free Agent | 0m
  5. Kamari Swyer | AM | Free Agent | 0m
  6. Kurt Zouma | CB | Free Agent | 0m
  7. Carlos Soler | CM | PSG | End of Loan
  8. Evan Ferguson | ST | Brighton | End of Loan
  9. Brad Dolaghan | Released
  10. Dondre Abraham | Released
  11. Mehmet Halim | Released
  12. Muhammed Judus |stroppy| sp*rs| £55m
  13. Michail Antonio | Released
  14. Kieran Casey | Swansea | Loan
  15. Edson Alvarez | Fenerbache | Loan with Option
  16. Emerson | Marseille | £1m
  17. Aguerd | Marseille | £20m
  18. Max Cornet | Genoa | Loan
Ron Eff
Posts: 618
Old WHO Number: 229621
Has liked: 19 times
Been liked: 154 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Ron Eff »

He doesn’t look purely a ball playing midfielder to me. He looks like he can do it all. 

I’m not saying we should pay £50m but I equally don’t think we should sign the wrong player just because they are available at £25-30m. If the deal can be done at £35m, and it’s who the manager really wants, I think it’s probably worth the extra £5m gamble.

He’s 21, POTY in his first season in the Premier League. There is a real chance of a lofty ceiling if he is as good as those that watch him have said. It’s incredibly lazy to say “yeah but they were shit”. Was Joe Cole not worth signing when we went down? Or Parker the next time?

Hypothetically, if he moves in a few years for north of £60m, people are going to say “we could have had him for £35m, another fuck up” much like they are with Etikite, who incidentally was generally deemed a flop on his immediate move from Reims to PSG, until he recovered his rep at Frankfurt.  

£50m is not the right value fwiw, but I think that’s posturing. He’ll go for less than that. 
User avatar
Lee Trundle
Posts: 3553
Old WHO Number: 33318
Been liked: 625 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Lee Trundle »

Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 22:09 You moaned about Wilson, but then again, we all did
 
🤔
Sir Alf
Posts: 2429
Old WHO Number: 10229
Has liked: 36 times
Been liked: 390 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Sir Alf »

Agree Russ, the Lille bloke looked powerful and runs for fun in possession and out of possession, covering and pressing at speed. Thats what we really miss since Rice left. 2 players like that and it would potentially transform us as a team.  

I would prioritise the no 17 from Lille too in other words. Get him in asap and pay the 20 million assuming we know that game against us was not a one off of course 😆
Russ of the BML
Posts: 1145
Old WHO Number: 14551
Has liked: 402 times
Been liked: 412 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Russ of the BML »

Just my two penneth FWIW.....

I am not sure Fernandes should be our target. We have Paqueta and so a ball playing midfielder is not a priority. For me, our priority should be Makua who is powerful and dynamic. And available for £15m. Our engine is what needs an upgrade. 

If I was Potter, I would be saying to Sulli please just go out today and secure Makua and Geuye and we will be pretty much sorted and could actually turn out quite an impressive first eleven.
Russ of the BML
Posts: 1145
Old WHO Number: 14551
Has liked: 402 times
Been liked: 412 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Russ of the BML »

Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:27
Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 18:15

We ain't paying anything like £50mil for him, but anything around £35mil would seem like good business

 
Paying 35m+ for a player that was available for 15m the season before isn’t good business.
Why? If he has 2 or 3 good seasons with us and then we sell him for £60m, that is good business.
Russ of the BML
Posts: 1145
Old WHO Number: 14551
Has liked: 402 times
Been liked: 412 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Russ of the BML »

southbankbornnbred wrote: 13 Aug 2025, 08:02 OK, asked a Southampton supporting mate of mine to give us his view of Fernandes in his own words. Pasted directly below. Apologies for any errors (he's not a writer!) and for the fact that he's a dithering Southampton fan who can't edit. He's from Hampshire, which is basically an illness!

“Most important of all hes a very good player. But hes not worth £50m yet. Hes skilful and more powerful then he looks, and he holds off players well. Great balance and excellent left foot. Hes creative, but usually from deep positions and thats why he sometimes doesn’t dominate games. You need to get him closer to the box. Last season, he tended to drop deep and play in front of our back line, picking up the ball from crap defenders because he was the only midfielder capable of beating the press.His passing is good, but he gives it away and will get better. But if hes going to play for a top ten Premier League team he needs to play at a higher speed than we did last season. We were utter shite last year and he was often our only good player. He sometimes got overwhelmed but because we had nobody apart from Tyler. Hes young and he can’t carry a team on his own. We didn’t help him.We’d be fucked if we lost him but it will give Still money to build a team. But hes far too good for the championship. He deserves to play better teams.Hes not a finished player He’s young give him time and he will turn into a force. But he needs to decide if he’s a more attacking or deep lying midfielder. At the moment he tries to do everything and gets caught out.If you sign him, we’ll be shite until we sign other players and you lot will be better. He feels like a Potter player more than Souceck. And he’s got to be better than Rodrigues who I know you hate!!!

We don't want Ward-Prowse back. He should stick to golf these days!!!"
Cheers for that.

I think we are going to get shafted over this. As your pal said, he is their best player, so they aint gonna let him go for £30m (which is probably what his actual value is). We need to be careful here that we don't pay for what he could be valued at in a few years. Personally, from what I have seen of him, I thought our early bid of £30m was pretty solid. Would be interesting to know what Soton's value is. 
southbankbornnbred
Posts: 1133
Old WHO Number: 14766
Has liked: 237 times
Been liked: 385 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post southbankbornnbred »

OK, asked a Southampton supporting mate of mine to give us his view of Fernandes in his own words. Pasted directly below. Apologies for any errors (he's not a writer!) and for the fact that he's a dithering Southampton fan who can't edit. He's from Hampshire, which is basically an illness!

“Most important of all hes a very good player. But hes not worth £50m yet. Hes skilful and more powerful then he looks, and he holds off players well. Great balance and excellent left foot. Hes creative, but usually from deep positions and thats why he sometimes doesn’t dominate games. You need to get him closer to the box. Last season, he tended to drop deep and play in front of our back line, picking up the ball from crap defenders because he was the only midfielder capable of beating the press.His passing is good, but he gives it away and will get better. But if hes going to play for a top ten Premier League team he needs to play at a higher speed than we did last season. We were utter shite last year and he was often our only good player. He sometimes got overwhelmed but because we had nobody apart from Tyler. Hes young and he can’t carry a team on his own. We didn’t help him.We’d be fucked if we lost him but it will give Still money to build a team. But hes far too good for the championship. He deserves to play better teams.Hes not a finished player He’s young give him time and he will turn into a force. But he needs to decide if he’s a more attacking or deep lying midfielder. At the moment he tries to do everything and gets caught out.If you sign him, we’ll be shite until we sign other players and you lot will be better. He feels like a Potter player more than Souceck. And he’s got to be better than Rodrigues who I know you hate!!!

We don't want Ward-Prowse back. He should stick to golf these days!!!"
Jean-Luc Paul Goddard
Posts: 347
Has liked: 39 times
Been liked: 148 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Jean-Luc Paul Goddard »

Eerie's right Jaan. You're ALWAYS moaning and being negative about everything, probably more than anyone else on this site. It's in the nature of things West Ham that you'll mostly be proved right but that doesn't make it any less gutless or tiresome.
Eerie Decent
Posts: 754
Has liked: 112 times
Been liked: 306 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Eerie Decent »

Furry muff. You win.

Enjoy the season.
Jaan Kenbrovin
Posts: 1112
Old WHO Number: 269499
Has liked: 52 times
Been liked: 240 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Jaan Kenbrovin »

You moaned about KWP on a free transfer ffs
No I didn't. I actually posted about signing him along with the other English targets, as being a preferable recruitment policy for the club.

You moaned about the keeper, who was touted at £25mil, we got him for £15mil, Leicester fans rave about him. 
I was against paying 25m for him and pointed out his stats last season didn't prove him to be the MASSIVE UPGRADE you claimed.

You moaned about signing a left back first, who looks mustard btw
No I pointed out the fact we spent half the Kudus money on a position we already had two players for, as not being priority.

You're moaning about signing a lad that looks mustard for £35mil
I've just givien you the context in which you've completely ignored.
Eerie Decent
Posts: 754
Has liked: 112 times
Been liked: 306 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Eerie Decent »

You moaned about KWP on a free transfer ffs
You moaned about the keeper, who was touted at £25mil, we got him for £15mil, Leicester fans rave about him
You moaned about signing a left back first, who looks mustard btw
You moaned about Wilson, but then again, we all did
You're moaning about signing a lad that looks mustard for £35mil

What is it you've not moaned about that I've deflected from?
Jaan Kenbrovin
Posts: 1112
Old WHO Number: 269499
Has liked: 52 times
Been liked: 240 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Jaan Kenbrovin »

Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 21:22
Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 21:10
Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 20:44
 
I was critical of the Kilman signing at the time, thought it was utter madness, mainly because the Wolves fans, to a man, were saying he was pony. I take note of stuff like that. I think the Callum Wilson signing is a shocker, for the same reasons everyone else does.

Signing a 21 year old who's just won his club's POTY in the Prem by a landslide, who is properly highly rated by those who have watched him regularly, for £35mil seems like decent business.

Slagging off EVERY single signing the club makes is easy work, which is exactly what you're doing. You can come back crowing about it if he's shit, keep schtum if he's quality and no one will mention it. Some of us are just trying to look at each signing on its merits.

Supporting this club is hard enough at the minute, I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive. I called this manager out when he went to Chelsea, never wanted him here, and I fucking hate our owners. But that doesn't mean I'm going to be a minge about absolutely everything, but fair play, you're sticking to your guns. Let's hope you're wrong about every single view you have, for the sake of West Ham, yeah?
 
That was a lot of words to simply say 'I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive'  Where as I'm simply being realistic. It's the same cycle as ever other pre season, people share an opinion that isn't blind optimism and you accuse them  of being against EVERYTHING, like a wounded child. 🙄

You're not being realistic, youre moaning about absolutely everything. Like a wounded child, ironically.

I'm a million miles from blind optimism, I'm trying to be objective about each signing. 

All fair enough though, I hope you enjoy the season more than you're anticipating. I hope the same for myself.
I haven't moaned about everything though. That's just a cunty deflection from  any point I've raised.  Here you are talking up spending 35m+ on a player that only last season was 15m, like criticism is beyond rational. That's the same amount we paid for Kudus and Paqueta, who were both internationals playing European football.

If you think he is better than both those players as investments I'm struggling to see why, but I don't believe for a second you do. You've just got trappy about him for the sake of being supportive,

If money was no object to the club it wouldn't bother me. Seeing as we are on a tight budget, and they are asking for the same amount as what we sold Kudus for, I'm not seeing this potential transfer as within our means or good business.
Eerie Decent
Posts: 754
Has liked: 112 times
Been liked: 306 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Eerie Decent »

Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 21:10
Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 20:44
Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:55
 
No I just see it as bad business. The same as when I pointed out 27m on Aguerd who went for 4m 2 years before was bad business. And spending 45m on Kilman was terrible business. 

You know, the sort of thing you end up being critical of eventually.
 
I was critical of the Kilman signing at the time, thought it was utter madness, mainly because the Wolves fans, to a man, were saying he was pony. I take note of stuff like that. I think the Callum Wilson signing is a shocker, for the same reasons everyone else does.

Signing a 21 year old who's just won his club's POTY in the Prem by a landslide, who is properly highly rated by those who have watched him regularly, for £35mil seems like decent business.

Slagging off EVERY single signing the club makes is easy work, which is exactly what you're doing. You can come back crowing about it if he's shit, keep schtum if he's quality and no one will mention it. Some of us are just trying to look at each signing on its merits.

Supporting this club is hard enough at the minute, I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive. I called this manager out when he went to Chelsea, never wanted him here, and I fucking hate our owners. But that doesn't mean I'm going to be a minge about absolutely everything, but fair play, you're sticking to your guns. Let's hope you're wrong about every single view you have, for the sake of West Ham, yeah?
 
That was a lot of words to simply say 'I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive'  Where as I'm simply being realistic. It's the same cycle as ever other pre season, people share an opinion that isn't blind optimism and you accuse them  of being against EVERYTHING, like a wounded child. 🙄

You're not being realistic, youre moaning about absolutely everything. Like a wounded child, ironically.

I'm a million miles from blind optimism, I'm trying to be objective about each signing. 

All fair enough though, I hope you enjoy the season more than you're anticipating. I hope the same for myself.
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3121
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 124 times
Been liked: 739 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post El Scorchio »

ragingbull wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 20:51 Well taken goal by Fernandes against Northampton 
There's a couple million more on the fee 





(joke)
Jaan Kenbrovin
Posts: 1112
Old WHO Number: 269499
Has liked: 52 times
Been liked: 240 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Jaan Kenbrovin »

Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 20:44
Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:55
Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:36 We had a different manager then.

Of course, hindsight is a wonderful thing, and our owners are shit.

But if the current manager thinks he'll transform us, then it will be money well spent.

But something tells me you are going to be fuming about every single thing to do with West Ham, Jaan, so yeah, let's agree, it's horrendous business.

Whatever next to moan about...
 
No I just see it as bad business. The same as when I pointed out 27m on Aguerd who went for 4m 2 years before was bad business. And spending 45m on Kilman was terrible business. 

You know, the sort of thing you end up being critical of eventually.
 
I was critical of the Kilman signing at the time, thought it was utter madness, mainly because the Wolves fans, to a man, were saying he was pony. I take note of stuff like that. I think the Callum Wilson signing is a shocker, for the same reasons everyone else does.

Signing a 21 year old who's just won his club's POTY in the Prem by a landslide, who is properly highly rated by those who have watched him regularly, for £35mil seems like decent business.

Slagging off EVERY single signing the club makes is easy work, which is exactly what you're doing. You can come back crowing about it if he's shit, keep schtum if he's quality and no one will mention it. Some of us are just trying to look at each signing on its merits.

Supporting this club is hard enough at the minute, I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive. I called this manager out when he went to Chelsea, never wanted him here, and I fucking hate our owners. But that doesn't mean I'm going to be a minge about absolutely everything, but fair play, you're sticking to your guns. Let's hope you're wrong about every single view you have, for the sake of West Ham, yeah?
 
 
That was a lot of words to simply say 'I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive'  Where as I'm simply being realistic. It's the same cycle as ever other pre season, people share an opinion that isn't blind optimism and you accuse them  of being against EVERYTHING, like a wounded child. 🙄

User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 3121
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 124 times
Been liked: 739 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post El Scorchio »

Vexed wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:21
El Scorchio" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:09
Vexed wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 18:31 I guess when your transfer strategy is so bad that you leave the most important buy until days before the season starts and then broadcast to the world how desperate we are to sign a midfielder, then you can't really be too surprised when selling clubs try to pull your pants down. We've done it to ourselves again. The business genius of Sully.

However, nobody ever accepts the first offer on the table, remember how outraged we were when the skullcaps offered a paltry 50m for Kudus followed by the complete capitulation only days later for a few pennies more? It's a negotiation. Southampton don't think they're getting 50m any more than we thought we were getting 85m for Kudus. However they're not quite as desperate or pathetic as Sully so we won't be getting a bargain. 

What I want to know is when is McCauley going to start earning his fucking money with his data (yawn) because it looks like he does most of his scouting on Match Of The Day and Sky Sports News. Where are the gems you cսnt? 
Assuming he and Potter are still in a job, the gems would likely come a little further down the line. Such is the state of the squad we’re having to pay decent sized amounts on established players to hopefully make an impact immediately. Caught in Sullivan’s interminable wheel of short sightedness. Best hope is they make a decent fist of it this season, ship out more of the deadwood and start getting in a few of these young players to start as squad members not required to drop right in and make an impact. We are so far behind we’ve got a lot to do to catch up with most other functional teams. We don’t even have a fully formed first XI, let alone squad. 
You could be right but Potter's decisions are not really helping his cause if longevity is his aim. Got one consistently high performing player, yeah let's play him out of position! Got fifty odd million wrapped up in two other wingers too - but let's not play with any wingers. Midfield was awful all last season - let's wait until four days before the start of the season to bid on a midfielder! We're terribly slow and injury prone up top - let's not prioritise a striker and then bring a really washed up one in eventually! It's been fucking mental behaviour. 
I hear you about (presumably) Bowen and/or Paqueta. He could play to his strengths a bit more also in terms of wide players. It's worth remembering though he inherited all those wingers rather than bought them plus the geezer he played successfully at RWB in his first game hasn't been seen since.

I really find it hard to blame him for us not buying a midfielder yet and also for Wilson. That's all on Sullivan and his mental behaviour. I am sure the club were relying on selling a few midfielders a lot quicker than we have- or indeed at all. But there is no way in hell Potter would have said if asked 'Yeah it's fine, just wait until the last week and then we'll move- I don't need to get the guy in in time to acclimatise and have preseason with the rest of them. Just get him in for the morning of the Sunderland match' No way. It'll be all Sullivan holding off as usual to do business as late as possible for whatever stupid reasons. You can't do much if the bloke who has to write the cheques isn't getting his chequebook out. Plus there's no way if told he can have one striker he goes 'Callum Wilson please.'
User avatar
ragingbull
Posts: 450
Old WHO Number: 210831
Has liked: 153 times
Been liked: 76 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post ragingbull »

Nice to see Nolan hugging the line.
User avatar
ragingbull
Posts: 450
Old WHO Number: 210831
Has liked: 153 times
Been liked: 76 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post ragingbull »

Well taken goal by Fernandes against Northampton 
Eerie Decent
Posts: 754
Has liked: 112 times
Been liked: 306 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Eerie Decent »

Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:55
Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:36 We had a different manager then.

Of course, hindsight is a wonderful thing, and our owners are shit.

But if the current manager thinks he'll transform us, then it will be money well spent.

But something tells me you are going to be fuming about every single thing to do with West Ham, Jaan, so yeah, let's agree, it's horrendous business.

Whatever next to moan about...
 
No I just see it as bad business. The same as when I pointed out 27m on Aguerd who went for 4m 2 years before was bad business. And spending 45m on Kilman was terrible business. 

You know, the sort of thing you end up being critical of eventually.
 
 
I was critical of the Kilman signing at the time, thought it was utter madness, mainly because the Wolves fans, to a man, were saying he was pony. I take note of stuff like that. I think the Callum Wilson signing is a shocker, for the same reasons everyone else does.

Signing a 21 year old who's just won his club's POTY in the Prem by a landslide, who is properly highly rated by those who have watched him regularly, for £35mil seems like decent business.

Slagging off EVERY single signing the club makes is easy work, which is exactly what you're doing. You can come back crowing about it if he's shit, keep schtum if he's quality and no one will mention it. Some of us are just trying to look at each signing on its merits.

Supporting this club is hard enough at the minute, I'm trying to at least stay a bit positive. I called this manager out when he went to Chelsea, never wanted him here, and I fucking hate our owners. But that doesn't mean I'm going to be a minge about absolutely everything, but fair play, you're sticking to your guns. Let's hope you're wrong about every single view you have, for the sake of West Ham, yeah?
User avatar
Iron Duke
Posts: 1088
Old WHO Number: 251573
Has liked: 112 times
Been liked: 313 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Iron Duke »

We should be more like Palace and find players in the £20m bracket. Surely this is why we are paying Macauley the big bucks? We’ve had our fingers burnt far too often paying over the odds for players. Sure, Fernandes might go on to be a £70m player, but right now he is £25-30m.

 
9898
Posts: 52
Been liked: 6 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post 9898 »

The one thing that's flcwftain is that history will be very, very kind to Steiden. 
Very, very good at his job and a real loss. 
Jaan Kenbrovin
Posts: 1112
Old WHO Number: 269499
Has liked: 52 times
Been liked: 240 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Jaan Kenbrovin »

Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:36 We had a different manager then.

Of course, hindsight is a wonderful thing, and our owners are shit.

But if the current manager thinks he'll transform us, then it will be money well spent.

But something tells me you are going to be fuming about every single thing to do with West Ham, Jaan, so yeah, let's agree, it's horrendous business.

Whatever next to moan about...
 
 
No I just see it as bad business. The same as when I pointed out 27m on Aguerd who went for 4m 2 years before was bad business. And spending 45m on Kilman was terrible business. 

You know, the sort of thing you end up being critical of eventually.
Vexed
Posts: 1035
Old WHO Number: 240179
Has liked: 3 times
Been liked: 206 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Vexed »

Jaan Kenbrovin" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 19:27
Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 18:15

We ain't paying anything like £50mil for him, but anything around £35mil would seem like good business

 
Paying 35m+ for a player that was available for 15m the season before isn’t good business.
It's great business if he's worth 70 next season innit, you fuckin length
Eerie Decent
Posts: 754
Has liked: 112 times
Been liked: 306 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Eerie Decent »

We had a different manager then.

Of course, hindsight is a wonderful thing, and our owners are shit.

But if the current manager thinks he'll transform us, then it will be money well spent.

But something tells me you are going to be fuming about every single thing to do with West Ham, Jaan, so yeah, let's agree, it's horrendous business.

Whatever next to moan about...
Jaan Kenbrovin
Posts: 1112
Old WHO Number: 269499
Has liked: 52 times
Been liked: 240 times

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2025 | Official Thread

Post Jaan Kenbrovin »

Eerie Decent" wrote: 12 Aug 2025, 18:15

We ain't paying anything like £50mil for him, but anything around £35mil would seem like good business
 
Paying 35m+ for a player that was available for 15m the season before isn’t good business.
Post Reply