Amazon Search and Bookmark
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!

Boxing

Forum area for all things that are non-football.
Forum rules
Whilst 'off-topic' means all non-football topics can be discussed. This is not a free for all. Rights to this area of the forum aren't implicit, and illegal, defamator, spammy or absuive topics will be removed, with the protagonist's sanctioned.
Post Reply
Nutsin
Posts: 2915
Old WHO Number: 274983
Has liked: 180 times
Been liked: 330 times

Boxing

Post Nutsin »

Fights that would have had a different outcome if both fighters were in their prime.

I’ll go Hagler v Leonard and Tyson v Hollyfield.

Who you got?
User avatar
zebthecat
Posts: 1894
Old WHO Number: 16911
Has liked: 371 times
Been liked: 235 times

Re: Boxing

Post zebthecat »

Wardley cartainly is a tough bastard and supremely fit.
It was a surprsingly good fight.
His dodge to the right punch avoiding move will need a rethink if/when he face Usyk as that will bring right on to Usyk's left hand.
User avatar
MaryMillingtonsGhost
Posts: 958
Old WHO Number: 300173
Has liked: 579 times
Been liked: 390 times

Re: Boxing

Post MaryMillingtonsGhost »

,
Posts: 1135
Has liked: 12 times
Been liked: 122 times

Re: Boxing

Post , »

Last night I watched the Parker Wardley fight. It was a cracker with both men going for it. Parker performed  as I expected but this tussle revealed just how good Wardley is at taking a punch let alone dishing it out. Parker hit Wardley with some blows that would have likely stopped Dubois and Joshua in their tracks but his opponent weathered these storms to hand out punishment of his own.

Well worth watching.
,
Posts: 1135
Has liked: 12 times
Been liked: 122 times

Re: Boxing

Post , »

Swiss, do you know about the first Law of Holes?
Swiss.
Posts: 1896
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 289 times
Been liked: 349 times

Re: Boxing

Post Swiss. »

, wrote: 24 Oct 2025, 16:14 Look Swiss, you think that  Hagler is a brawler so own it. It is not my intention to get you to change your mind but I think that you’ll find on here  the consensus is that Hagler ranks in the pantheon of greats. 

By all means seek to justify your opinion but you need to do research before simply denigrating Minter. He was a good fighter on his day and btw he lasted just as long against Hagler going three rounds like Thomas Hearns.

And regarding brawlers can you list some other boxers in that category so that we have a further laugh.
Hagler won fights because he was a human punch bag. No class in that. 
,
Posts: 1135
Has liked: 12 times
Been liked: 122 times

Re: Boxing

Post , »

Look Swiss, you think that  Hagler is a brawler so own it. It is not my intention to get you to change your mind but I think that you’ll find on here  the consensus is that Hagler ranks in the pantheon of greats. 

By all means seek to justify your opinion but you need to do research before simply denigrating Minter. He was a good fighter on his day and btw he lasted just as long against Hagler going three rounds like Thomas Hearns.

And regarding brawlers can you list some other boxers in that category so that we have a further laugh.
Swiss.
Posts: 1896
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 289 times
Been liked: 349 times

Re: Boxing

Post Swiss. »

Swiss. wrote: 24 Oct 2025, 13:42
, wrote: 24 Oct 2025, 12:03 Alan Minter, Olympic medalist, middleweight world champion etc described Hagler as the most accurate puncher he ever fought against.

That is good enough for me to discount any chance of Hagler being a brawler.
He also complained about him using his head in their fight hence the bleeding. 
 
Oh and the great Alan Minter who could really compare Hagler to the others he fought like Hearns, Leonard and Duran....oh wait a minute. 
Swiss.
Posts: 1896
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 289 times
Been liked: 349 times

Re: Boxing

Post Swiss. »

, wrote: 24 Oct 2025, 12:03 Alan Minter, Olympic medalist, middleweight world champion etc described Hagler as the most accurate puncher he ever fought against.

That is good enough for me to discount any chance of Hagler being a brawler.
He also complained about him using his head in their fight hence the bleeding. 
Swiss.
Posts: 1896
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 289 times
Been liked: 349 times

Re: Boxing

Post Swiss. »

Takashi Miike" wrote: 24 Oct 2025, 10:37 "For me Hagler was not a good boxer"

amazing. up there with the dopiest fucking comments ever
Love a bit of bait. Every time you mugs fall for it😀
,
Posts: 1135
Has liked: 12 times
Been liked: 122 times

Re: Boxing

Post , »

Alan Minter, Olympic medalist, middleweight world champion etc described Hagler as the most accurate puncher he ever fought against.

That is good enough for me to discount any chance of Hagler being a brawler.
User avatar
Far Cough UKunt
Posts: 1778
Has liked: 447 times
Been liked: 717 times

Re: Boxing

Post Far Cough UKunt »

You can box for points, see Leonard, or slug it out, see Hagler, both styles are valid.
User avatar
Massive Attack
Posts: 6597
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 3787 times
Been liked: 1984 times

Re: Boxing

Post Massive Attack »

Hagler was so good. 😂
User avatar
Takashi Miike
Posts: 3599
Old WHO Number: 233644
Has liked: 906 times
Been liked: 1304 times

Re: Boxing

Post Takashi Miike »

"For me Hagler was not a good boxer"

amazing. up there with the dopiest fucking comments ever
Swiss.
Posts: 1896
Old WHO Number: 220150
Has liked: 289 times
Been liked: 349 times

Re: Boxing

Post Swiss. »

Almost 3 rounds of mahem. For me Hagler was not a good boxer just a brawler with an iron jaw. He used his head and elbows a ,lot and got away with it. 




 
User avatar
Massive Attack
Posts: 6597
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 3787 times
Been liked: 1984 times

Re: Boxing

Post Massive Attack »

Monsieur merde de cheval" wrote: 21 Oct 2025, 03:34
Council Scum" wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:47
zico wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:23 The ridiculous thing is Nigel freely admits that he burned the candle at both ends massively.  Can't imagine what he would have been like if he had been fully committed to the craft.
You'll find most fighters did back then, most of the 80's top fighters were on coke. 
I was still serving in 1990 when the Benn/Eubank pre fight  was in full swing.
Benn served in the RRF and fought in the Army boxing team ..i was on remedial SWIMMING and Benn was using military bases for fitness ..courtesy of the Army Boxing Team..
His taste in music was dog shit...and a bit of a pillock .
But that's the Army...if you excel at any sport you get away with anything
My uncle knew him an all whilst also serving and being based out in Germany back in those times. 
Monsieur merde de cheval
Posts: 1827
Has liked: 1174 times
Been liked: 608 times

Re: Boxing

Post Monsieur merde de cheval »

Council Scum" wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:47
zico wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:23 The ridiculous thing is Nigel freely admits that he burned the candle at both ends massively.  Can't imagine what he would have been like if he had been fully committed to the craft.
You'll find most fighters did back then, most of the 80's top fighters were on coke. 
Like the ZULUS were bang on the WHIZZ
Monsieur merde de cheval
Posts: 1827
Has liked: 1174 times
Been liked: 608 times

Re: Boxing

Post Monsieur merde de cheval »

Council Scum" wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:47
zico wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:23 The ridiculous thing is Nigel freely admits that he burned the candle at both ends massively.  Can't imagine what he would have been like if he had been fully committed to the craft.
You'll find most fighters did back then, most of the 80's top fighters were on coke. 
I was still serving in 1990 when the Benn/Eubank pre fight  was in full swing.
Benn served in the RRF and fought in the Army boxing team ..i was on remedial SWIMMING and Benn was using military bases for fitness ..courtesy of the Army Boxing Team..
His taste in music was dog shit...and a bit of a pillock .
But that's the Army...if you excel at any sport you get away with anything
Monsieur merde de cheval
Posts: 1827
Has liked: 1174 times
Been liked: 608 times

Re: Boxing

Post Monsieur merde de cheval »

SurfaceAgentX2Zero wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 09:54 Honeyghan beat Don Curry, IIRC the best pound for pound boxer in the world at the time. For that, he must get in any top 10, even though he quickly sank without trace. Excellent as he was, I don't think you can put Michael Watson in the Top 10 - he was very much the third man in a UK trinity.

My left-fielder would be Dennis Andries.
Dennis Andries was a proper warrior...same for Carl Thompson.
Cruiserweight back in the day had it's fair share of blokes you'd want on your side when the shit hits the fan.
I remember staying up for the Honeyghan /Curry fight .
big at the time , but looking back I'm ashamed I backed Honeyghan ...he's a tool of the highest order
Nutsin
Posts: 2915
Old WHO Number: 274983
Has liked: 180 times
Been liked: 330 times

Re: Boxing

Post Nutsin »

Fights you’ve seen live.

I saw Nigel Benn win at the Royal Albert Hall in a commonwealth title fight.

I saw Lennox Lewis fight Klitschko at the Staples center in L A. Watching the fight live looked a lot different than when I watched it on HBO later that week.  Watching Live it never looked close, Lewis was dominant and we were pretty close to the ring. 

A title fight at Caesar's palace is on my bucket list.

I Can tell you this Lennox Lewis didn’t do Coke.
Council Scum
Posts: 661
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 235 times

Re: Boxing

Post Council Scum »

zico wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 12:23 The ridiculous thing is Nigel freely admits that he burned the candle at both ends massively.  Can't imagine what he would have been like if he had been fully committed to the craft.
You'll find most fighters did back then, most of the 80's top fighters were on coke. 
zico
Posts: 4538
Old WHO Number: 10629
Has liked: 480 times
Been liked: 289 times

Re: Boxing

Post zico »

The ridiculous thing is Nigel freely admits that he burned the candle at both ends massively.  Can't imagine what he would have been like if he had been fully committed to the craft.
User avatar
MaryMillingtonsGhost
Posts: 958
Old WHO Number: 300173
Has liked: 579 times
Been liked: 390 times

Re: Boxing

Post MaryMillingtonsGhost »

zico wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 11:36 I remember when Benn went to the US to fight Iran Barkley.  This was a guy who had beaten Hearns and lost on a split decision to Roberto Durán and took on an undefeated Michael Nunn dropping a close majority decision.  Benn beat him on the three knockdown rule in the first round, although to be fair he could have been knocked out himself.  One of the most brutal first rounds I have seen where any form of defensive boxing went out of the window. 



 
 
 
 
Council Scum
Posts: 661
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 235 times

Re: Boxing

Post Council Scum »

zico wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 11:36 Benn was an entertainer, probably the most exciting fighter I've seen, up there with Hatton for pure up and at 'em.  You were never disappointed bar his last few fights when he had gone.  The McClellan fight did for Benn what the Watson fight did for Eubank. Eubank said Benn was by far the hardest puncher he had faced.  I remember when Benn went to the US to fight Iran Barkley.  This was a guy who had beaten Hearns and lost on a split decision to Roberto Durán and took on an undefeated Michael Nunn dropping a close majority decision.  Benn beat him on the three knockdown rule in the first round, although to be fair he could have been knocked out himself.  One of the most brutal first rounds I have seen where any form of defensive boxing went out of the window.  I think Eubank paced himself and had the better chin although I would argue Benn should have got the decsion in their second fight.
The story behind the draw, whoever won, was contractually agreed to sign with Don King, the draw meant neither had to sign and could walk away free agents... Don wasn't happy it ended a draw as the contract didn't factor that in. 
zico
Posts: 4538
Old WHO Number: 10629
Has liked: 480 times
Been liked: 289 times

Re: Boxing

Post zico »

Benn was an entertainer, probably the most exciting fighter I've seen, up there with Hatton for pure up and at 'em.  You were never disappointed bar his last few fights when he had gone.  The McClellan fight did for Benn what the Watson fight did for Eubank. Eubank said Benn was by far the hardest puncher he had faced.  I remember when Benn went to the US to fight Iran Barkley.  This was a guy who had beaten Hearns and lost on a split decision to Roberto Durán and took on an undefeated Michael Nunn dropping a close majority decision.  Benn beat him on the three knockdown rule in the first round, although to be fair he could have been knocked out himself.  One of the most brutal first rounds I have seen where any form of defensive boxing went out of the window.  I think Eubank paced himself and had the better chin although I would argue Benn should have got the decsion in their second fight.
Council Scum
Posts: 661
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 235 times

Re: Boxing

Post Council Scum »

SurfaceAgentX2Zero wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 11:00
Council Scum" wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 09:58
SurfaceAgentX2Zero wrote: 20 Oct 2025, 09:54 Honeyghan beat Don Curry, IIRC the best pound for pound boxer in the world at the time. For that, he must get in any top 10, even though he quickly sank without trace. Excellent as he was, I don't think you can put Michael Watson in the Top 10 - he was very much the third man in a UK trinity.

My left-fielder would be Dennis Andries.
See my list mate... 
Ahhh. Fair dos. I think I might have Froch in there instead of Khan, if only for the two Kessler fights. And it's difficult to separate Eubank and Benn.
 
 
As much as I loved Benn back then, for me Eubank was better. 

Khan won titles at 3 weights and competed at 4, people take the piss like he was shit, because he got KO'd a few times (So did Lewis) and call him chinny (check the Maidana fight, he had a chin) but talent wise, he was one of the best. 
Post Reply