Callum Marshall

[Takashi Miike]

"Another hat-trick, this time against Fulham in the PL U18 Cup. Poxy camera angle, but worth watching for his brilliant third goal. Early days, but this lad could be a potential superstar https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tddKySeAWDA"

[Iron Duke]

A great win for the U21s tonight. 4-0 at Colchester. Into the quarter finals.

[Side of Ham]

"Erm, maybe I know because I read this forum oh and that Moyes is consistent with his set up and he's still West Ham's manager? You really are a dickhead poster Willwall.....glad it was you last comment on the subject as you are embarrassing yourself with you thick questions.....but you really do lie on here so it's unlikely isn't it......"

[Fauxstralian]

Ferguson of Brighton is possibly a different case as at 18 he is a big unit and looks capable of handling himself Moyes of course is very conservative and not likely to take chances with young players. I know Newcastle have lots of midfield injuries but notice they have thrown in 17yo Lewis Miley into games like PSG away & Man Utd. A game where he came up against 18yo Kobbie Mainoo of Man U If they are good enough they are old enough

[Willtell]

Except you were moaning about the football which was why I asked how you knew the football was bad. And you've shown yourself to be a liar about several things so I just don't believe you...that's my last comment on the subject.

[Side of Ham]

See Willwall this is where you are a dickhead poster….I’ve also told you I do watch the youth games as they play a nice style of football….that’s why I tend to comment about those youth players….you dick.

[Willtell]

"Side Opinions are one thing to be respected. But when you don't watch games nor stream games, all you're doing is repeatedly moaning on WHO for what purpose? None. You gave up being a fan years ago and you know that's true. . To claim you know what to moan about because you repeat my post on Moyes' team selection is just ridiculous. That's not an opinion - that's plagiarism."

[Side of Ham]

"Manuel - No, it’s a forum to have opinions on you dick…."

[daveyg]

LAF. Ferguson get minutes in every game when he's in the match day squad. He's had a few injuries. Marshall and Mubama played a .ot of games last season. Both are deceptively quicker and stronger than it appears. Both have a very good injury record compared to most youth players who are quite susceptible to growing pains. Marshall missed a game because of illness but came back and scored in the next game. Most of Steve Potts team are mainly injury free. Hopefully that continues. Under a Der Zerbi type manager Both would of had minutes galore this season. Brighton used 6 u21's against Chelsea. Their youth are NOT by a long way as good as ours. The sooner we get rid of Moyes the sooner our club will progress forward not sideways or backwards.

[Manuel]

"Side - Give it a rest ffs, you're all over the place. Let's pick up this debate next season when I'm sure you will give a subjective view on Mubama's qualities, or otherwise, under a new gaffer."

[Side of Ham]

"Hmmmm, because there enough posters on here confirming it by by posting this type of thing.... Willwall 12:50 Mon Dec 4 Re: Moyes Out ""Add to that the fact that we don't have an orthodox striker or left winger. So he plays all 6 together rather than buy or introduce new problems for himself. That's why we end up with Paqueta on LW. Soucek as Attacking Midfielder and Bowen as central striker. Maybe that's why we don't buy players to fill these positions? I reckon that Moyes knows his problems get bigger if he introduces Mubama or Cornet to win the game. If they play well he'll only need to find another reason to drop someone so better to keep them out the side..."" How is Mubama supposed to succeed or give it his best shot at getting in the 1st team if the managers set up is not wanting an Orthodox striker?"

[Willtell]

Hmm! But how do you know these things when you posted this recently? Side of Ham 1:34 Thu Nov 9 Re: Straw Poll: Would you sack Moyes if we lose to Forest? ...I don’t do streams I just catch the result so I also don’t do ‘knicker’ wetting…..Moyes’s football is that bad I don’t entertain it…..I’ll wait on for a new manager and then give them the benefit….. and IF there is any joy it’s few and far between…not enough to warrant any real jubilation…..FOMO about West Ham is now gone for me…..glad you are willing to pretend to put up with it though…

[Side of Ham]

So Manuel you disagree with me and think that Mubama should be judged on his ability whilst feeding off little to no service as a young striker trying to establish himself under Moyes shit set up? YOU lost this mince fest of yours when you couldn't state an actual striker Moyes has brought in or had at his disposal that works in his shit system.....it's always been a converted midfielder or winger.....now just mince off.....

[Manuel]

"Side - So I was right the first time, you CLEARLY don't think he can be judged in any way, shape or form while Moyes is here, despite saying earlier that you never suggested that. Don't bother denying it again. I think he can be (judged) in part. So let's agree to disagree and move on."

[Side of Ham]

Manuel ANY youth striker will look like his overall game & technique doesn’t look good enough because the position is a poison chalice under Moyes…..some half decent strikers have been made to look like their overall game & technique is not good enough. He’s hardly the manager to iron out his technique and add to his overall game he basically saps that out of some proper decent players.

[Manuel]

"Right, so he can be judged, in part, despite Moyes, and his overall game, technique etc doesn't appear to be good enough, but like I said he's still got time. Hopefully he will look like Van Basten after Moyes has left."

[Side of Ham]

"Manuel, where did I say Mubama can’t be judged? What I did say is he shouldn’t be judged on playing Moyes’s set up, I say this because every other striker we’ve had has failed under Moyes and a few of them have been established strikers……why?…..he makes them feed off scraps……you give us an example of a senior striker working well with Moyes and it will be a converted midfielder/winger….."

[Manuel]

What? I'm just giving an example that you can still go on to make it if you still haven't as a striker when you're around 19/20. That's it.

[Manuel]

What? I'm just giving an example that you can still go on to make it if you still haven't as a striker when you're around 19/20. That's it.

[marty feldman]

Manuel . Harry kane barely scored a goal in his loan spells . With orient Leicester Norwich and Millwall . You're either motivated or you ain't . He was vastly more motivated at the N17 mob than the others. Under a manager that plays youngsters like redknapp pardew lyall greenwood our youngsters would thrive. Mubama and marshall included.

[Manuel]

"Side - Come on, I'm not getting involved in a long debate here, but you can't just say he can't be judged at all just because he's been feeding off of scraps. You can often tell a lot about a player with their movement, fleet of foot, first touch etc, and Mubama didn't look that great when in possession on Thursday, albeit that wasn't often, giving it away few times, he still looks very raw. The general opinion seems to be he won't make it, and no shame in that as it's as tough as it's ever been, even more so if you're a young forward, but there is still hope for him, Moyes or not. Look at Kane, he was farmed out to Millwall at 19. One comparison you could make is H??jlund at Man Utd, only 20 but already played in Serie A and been transferred to one of the biggest clubs in the world for around 60 mil, the kid is on a completely different level to Mubama, again no shame in that but as a guide that is how far away Mubama is from being a top level PL striker. It's tough."

[Side of Ham]

"LAF why is it being romantic to want a successful youth team to produce a couple of 1st team players as they shown they have a winning mentality? And also you agree with Moyes when it’s his set up of feeding off scraps that will prevent them having a chances to impress? They play football at the moment in an attacking set up to then have to be shown a new opposite way of playing? It’s likely Rice got his chance to succeed because of Billic showing he could fit in….had he not done that Moyes would have dithered with his opportunities. I’m sure it was a long term illness/injury to Obiang that was his real chance under Moyes (could be wrong though) As for Mubama & Marshall….it’s likely to be they won’t make it but it’ll be due in part if not whole, to the fact Moyes has ruined every experienced striker under his management and they need chances to score first not half arsed scraps to be judged on."

[Ron Eff]

"I personally don’t think Mubama will make it in the Premier League. He’ll be a steady Championship level player I’m sure, but I don’t see that he has any particularly outstanding elements to his game. Unless it’s deceptive he doesn’t seem blessed with great pace, or able to beat a player with good feet and touch isn’t exceptional. Marshall on the other hand seems to have much more. Like a left sided, right footed version of Bowen. I have much higher hopes there. Hope I’m wrong on Mubama obviously, I just don’t see the fuss. Would still have him playing ahead of Ings though which is pretty damning."

[LAF]

"Sorry to disagree with the romantics on here but I agree with Moyes - there aren’t many under 20s starting in the Prem. It’s a big ask and a big risk. Even Brighton’s talented youngster, Ferguson - perhaps an exception - often gets rested and comes off the bench. The skill levels may be there with some exceptionally talented youngsters, but The Prem is tough, physically and mentally and chiefly requires other levels of maturity. Also, need to consider protecting youngsters from progressive injuries later on in their careers if pushed too hard, too soon. It did for Michael Owen, Norman Whiteside and, maybe, Theo Walcott. Barcelona right now are showing a dereliction of care to their youngsters by thrusting them into big games too early: look at Fati, loaned out to Brighton - injured; Gavii - injured; Yamal, at only 17, will be the next to breakdown if he is continually overused. That said, I do agree we should look to find ways to blood Mubama and Marshall at a quicker rate, if they are the real deal, to put them into firm contention for next season."

[the exile]

"feet - I don't always agree with daveyg but it's clear he knows a good deal more about football than you. daveyg - I hope you're right about Marshall. I agree that he has the best chance of making it. I can't help thinking of Freddie Sears, who had a similarly spectacular scoring record at U21 level but didn't have enough to make it at the top level. I can see that Marshall has a better all-round game and looks a bit more robust, so here's hoping. He should probably go out on loan as soon as possible."

[Side of Ham]

Twofaced = Slater